Conciseness

The body is efficient — commands, conditions, and workflows with little concept re-teaching — but has minor trimmable fat: "Use this skill to analyze Antithesis test runs." duplicates the description, the version string appears twice (frontmatter and body), and the property-investigation step e paragraph is wordy. Fits the 4 anchor ('minor instances of over-explanation'), not 5.

Actionability

Copy-paste-ready commands are present ("snouty doctor --json", the jq tenant pipeline, "snouty runs --json events ${RUN_ID} ${PROPERTY_NAME}", "snouty runs --json build-logs ${RUN_ID}") with explicit stop conditions, but run discovery, log download, and property parsing are deferred to reference files rather than shown — mostly executable with minor gaps, the 4 anchor rather than fully covering common cases in-body.

Workflow Clarity

Workflows are clearly sequenced with explicit validation and error recovery: the preflight gate ("Proceed only when the top-level `ok` is `true` and the `api_key` check's `status` is `ok`. Otherwise relay the failing check's `message`/`notes` and stop"), 404 handling for non-triageable runs, the incomplete-run fallback (failure_moment + build-logs), and a closing Self-Review checklist — matching the 5 anchor (explicit validation steps, feedback loops, checklists).

Progressive Disclosure

The body states an explicit disclosure policy ("Do NOT read them all up front — only read a reference file when you are told to. Each reference file is mentioned by name at the point where it is needed") and all five references/ files cited by name (run-discovery.md, run-info.md, properties.md, logs.md, instrumentation.md) exist and are invoked at their point of need, one level deep — the 5 anchor.

Specificity

The description lists seven concrete actions ("look up runs, check status, investigate failed properties (assertions), view metadata, download logs, inspect findings, and examine environmental details"), giving comprehensive coverage of the triage domain with no notable gaps, matching the top anchor.

Completeness

It explicitly answers what (the enumerated triage actions) and when ("Load after a run completes or when investigating a failure"), matching the anchor requiring both with concrete trigger phrases; not 4, since the when-clause is explicit rather than improvable.

Trigger Term Quality

Natural user phrasing is well covered — "test reports", "check status", "download logs", "investigating a failure" — and includes synonyms such as "properties (assertions)" and "findings", fitting the comprehensive-synonyms anchor rather than the 'a few natural terms missing' anchor at 4.

Distinctiveness Conflict Risk

"Triage Antithesis test reports" carves out a clear niche, but "investigating a failure" would also naturally route to the closely related antithesis-debug skill, so there is minor overlap risk with sibling skills — the 4 anchor, not the minimal-conflict 5 anchor.