Content
85%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An impressively actionable and well-structured skill body with copy-paste commands, exact grammars, explicit validation loops, and a clean one-level-deep reference bundle. The main cost is token efficiency: deliberate redundancy of the core pledge and inlined contracts from full-workflow.md make it longer than the guidance requires.
Suggestions
State the no-implementation/approval-authorizes-plan-only pledge once in the opening contract and reference it elsewhere with a short tag (e.g. 'per the no-implementation pledge'); it is currently repeated in six places across the body.
Replace the 100+ word review-modifier sentence in INTENT ROUTING with two or three shorter sentences and defer the convergence-contract details (bounded rounds, blocker eligibility, approval-with-notes) to full-workflow.md, which already documents them.
Consolidate the repeated pointers to references/full-workflow.md into a single 'shared mechanics' note in the routing section, keeping only the per-path load instruction.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and free of concept over-explanation, but it is noticeably repetitive: the no-implementation/approval-authorizes-plan-only pledge is restated roughly six times (persona intro, sticky plan mode, opening contract, example announcement, "Approval is not execution" invariant, approval gate, stop rules), pointers to references/full-workflow.md appear four times, and the review-modifier paragraph is a single 100+ word sentence packing an entire convergence contract that already lives in the reference file. It is not a 2 because nothing is padded with knowledge Claude already has, and not a 4 because the redundancy goes beyond minor trimmable instances. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is fully executable: a copy-paste scaffold command with all flags ("node \"<skill-root>/scripts/scaffold-plan.mjs\" <slug> [--clear|--unclear] --draft-only [--review-required]"), a literal spawn JSON payload plus an explicit v1-to-v2 rewrite rule, exact task-row grammar ("- [ ] N. <title>" / "- [ ] F<number>. <title>"), and the exact mandatory first line. Not a 4 because the commands and grammars are copy-paste ready and cover the common cases. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The multi-step process is clearly sequenced (the opening contract's numbered 1-6 preview, intent routing with an on-the-fence tie-break, then scaffold, gate, review, stop) and validation is explicit with a feedback loop: "Before handoff, run a structural self-check over the plan: verify that every implementation row and final-verifier row is column-zero... and repair the plan before handoff if any check fails", plus agent fallback rules ("Fallback only when the child is completed without the deliverable... or no longer running") and explicit terminal stop rules. Not a 4 because checkpoints are explicit and checklisted rather than merely present. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The 111-line body is an overview that defers deep mechanics to a verified bundle: three reference files (full-workflow.md, intent-clear.md, intent-unclear.md) each signaled with explicit load conditions ("Read **`references/intent-clear.md`**" on the CLEAR route, "Read the phase you are in" for shared mechanics), and two real scripts referenced by exact invocation path. References are one level deep — the reference files point only to each other and back to SKILL.md, with no nested chains. Not a 4 because the split and navigation are clean with no organization gaps. | 5 / 5 |
Total | 18 / 20 Passed |