Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The instructional core is excellent: a tightly sequenced 7-step workflow with templates, hard constraints, and a validation checklist. The main weakness is structural — the entire 17-chapter book outline is inlined in SKILL.md with no reference files, inflating token cost and leaving the skill monolithic despite otherwise good organization.
Suggestions
Move the 全书章节结构 outline (~250 lines) to a bundle file such as references/book-outline.md and keep only a one-line pointer plus the chapter-positioning question from Step 1, so it is loaded only when needed.
Add one complete example SVG (e.g. the 论证链结构图 for the 可转债 example) so the SVG generation step — currently only described as "用 bash_tool 把 SVG 代码写入 .svg 文件" — is copy-paste ready.
Consider moving the 示例输出片段 and the 论证链填写模板 into a references/ file if they grow, keeping SKILL.md as the overview and checklist.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The workflow sections (Steps 1–7, 写作禁忌, 检查清单) are dense and every line earns its place, but ~250 of 485 lines are the complete 17-chapter book outline inlined in SKILL.md, which is reference material rather than instructions. That single block keeps it at 'mostly efficient but includes content that should be tightened/moved', not anchor 4; it is not anchor 2 because the instructional core is not padded and does not explain concepts Claude already knows. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is highly concrete: file path pattern "markdown/<章节编号>_<小节slug>.md", length target "2000~4000 字", SVG constraints "viewBox='0 0 800 400'"/"不超过4色", a fill-in 论证链 template, a paste-ready compliance block, and an example output snippet. Not 5 because the one common execution path — generating an SVG — is directed only as "用 bash_tool 把 SVG 代码写入 .svg 文件" with no actual SVG example to copy. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Seven explicitly sequenced steps (理解定位 → 论证链 → 骨架 → SVG → 数据 → 实操 → 方法论) ending in a mandatory 执行检查清单 that functions as a validation gate ("必须全部通过" for the 论证链 items). Matches anchor 5's 'clear sequence with explicit validation steps and checklists'; below-5 would require missing checkpoints, which the checklist supplies. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body has clear section headers and a well-organized flow, but there are no bundle files at all (no references/, scripts/, assets/) and the 250-line 全书章节结构 outline — exactly the content that belongs in a separate reference file — is inlined. This is the anchor-3 pattern ('content that should be separate is inline'); not anchor 2 because the rest of the structure and navigation within SKILL.md is good, not minimal. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |