Content
70%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-engineered orchestration document: the phase sequence, gates, checklists, and error-recovery paths are exemplary, and commands/paths are concrete. Its weaknesses are repetition-heavy emphasis padding the token budget, and a 277-line body that inlines the full Phase 2 playbook instead of pushing it to a referenced file the way Phases 1 and 3 do.
Suggestions
Move the detailed Phase 2 playbook (prompt template, cross-pollination round, selection criteria, common mistakes) into a pr-try-fix.md phase doc like pr-preflight.md/pr-report.md, leaving only the mandate, model list, and time budget in SKILL.md.
Consolidate the repeated 'Phase 2 is mandatory / never skip / no exceptions' statements into one clearly flagged rule; the sync-mode rule also appears three times (Critical Rules, mandatory paragraph, Common Mistakes).
Trim the ~90-minute budget paragraph to its actionable rules (run each model once, write content.md after each attempt, stop at 90 minutes or when progress stalls) and drop the restated rationale.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly dense operational detail with no basic-concept padding, but it could be tightened: the Phase 2 mandate is repeated at least four times ("THIS PHASE IS MANDATORY. YOU MUST NEVER SKIP IT. NO EXCEPTIONS", the Critical Rules bullet, the checklist, and Common Mistakes), and the ~90-minute budget paragraph re-states the same stop-early rule three ways. This matches 'mostly efficient but includes some unnecessary explanation or could be tightened'. Not 4 because the repetition and the long time-budget block are more than minor instances. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is largely copy-paste ready: exact commands ('pwsh .github/scripts/EstablishBrokenBaseline.ps1 -Restore'), an exact output-directory tree, a filled-in try-fix prompt template, a content.md template, and an error-recovery table with fixes. It misses 5 because key steps remain placeholders — the prompt template's '{bug description}', '{test command}', and 'invoke try-fix skill via a general-purpose task agent with that model' never show how to select the model or assemble the inputs — so the common case is not fully self-contained. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The three phases are explicitly sequenced with per-phase gates ('Gate: Phases 1-2 must be complete'), validation checkpoints (checklist items, mandatory per-attempt content.md updates, test pass/fail required before fix selection), feedback loops (retry limits in the Environment Blockers table, cleanup-and-retry in Common Errors), and a Quick Reference table. This matches the top anchor 'clear sequence with explicit validation steps; feedback loops for error recovery; checklists'. Despite touching git state, validation and recovery steps are present, so the destructive-operation cap does not apply. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Phase instruction docs are clearly signaled one level deep ('Read and follow `.github/pr-review/pr-preflight.md`'), but no bundle files exist (no references/, scripts/, assets/) while the body references paths like `.github/skills/try-fix/SKILL.md` and `.github/scripts/EstablishBrokenBaseline.ps1` that are not part of this skill's bundle. Meanwhile the very detailed Phase 2 material (~120 lines of prompt templates, rounds, and selection rules) is inlined in SKILL.md where it belongs in a separate phase file, matching 'content that should be separate is inline'. Not 2 because overall structure and navigation (headers, Quick Reference) are genuinely good. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |