Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is exceptionally actionable, with concrete Errado/Certo pairs, ready-to-use copy templates for every common case, and explicit quality gates including a rewrite-until-clean feedback loop. It is held back by inlined template catalogs that duplicate the designated external guide, some re-taught copywriting fundamentals, an off-scope and self-contradictory code-comment section, and references to files that are not part of the bundle.
Suggestions
Move the full template catalogs (headline formulas, CTA lists, microcopy examples, and the per-section landing page specs) into the referenced docs/skill-guides/marketing-copy.md and keep only a compact summary plus the pointer in SKILL.md — the skill already designates that file for 'formulas, templates de copy e exemplos mais longos', so the inline duplication works against progressive disclosure.
Trim sections that restate knowledge Claude already has — the AIDA walkthrough and the generic Regras de Ouro — down to only the project-specific deviations (e.g., 'AIDA é uma opção quando fizer sentido', specific banned patterns and Errado/Certo pairs that encode house style).
Remove or rewrite the 'Regra de Código Limpo' section: it is off-scope for a copywriting skill and internally contradictory (first allowing comments for non-obvious context, then demanding 'Nenhum comentário em código').
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Sections like the AIDA progression ("ATTENTION → Headline que para o scroll...") and the seven "Regras de Ouro" restate copywriting fundamentals Claude already knows, and the trailing "Regra de Código Limpo" section is off-scope for a copywriting skill (and self-contradictory: comments are first allowed for non-obvious context, then "Nenhum comentário em código"). Mostly efficient because the bulk is prescriptive house-style content with Errado/Certo pairs rather than generic explanation, but the padding is more than minor — matching anchor 3, below anchor 4 and above anchor 2. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | The guidance is fully concrete and copy-paste ready for a copywriting skill: five headline formulas with worked examples ("Relatórios profissionais sem saber Excel"), ready-to-use CTA strings ("Começar meu teste grátis"), state-by-state microcopy (Default/Loading/Sucesso, 404, empty states), a fill-in brand voice template, and per-section landing page content specs. Specific examples comprehensively cover the common cases, matching anchor 5 for an instruction-only skill. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Explicit validation checkpoints are present — the Gate ("Copy com padrões AI visíveis não sai") and the Checkpoint with a genuine rewrite-until-clean feedback loop ("Marcar cada violação encontrada, reescrever a frase ... e reler de novo até a passada inteira não achar nenhuma"). Not anchor 5 because the end-to-end sequence (define brand voice → write → gate → handoff) is implicit in topic-ordered sections rather than laid out as ordered steps; well above anchor 3 because checkpoints and an error-recovery loop are explicitly stated. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | References are one level deep and clearly signaled ("consultar `docs/skill-guides/marketing-copy.md` apenas quando necessario"), but roughly 200 lines of template catalogs and landing-page specs are inlined even though the skill itself says formulas, templates, and longer examples belong in the external guide — matching anchor 3's 'content that could be in a separate file is inline'. Additionally, none of the referenced paths (policies/*, docs/skill-guides/*, skills/91-unslop/*) exist in the skill bundle, so they cannot be verified, keeping it below anchor 4. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |