Content
77%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
This is a strong, execution-ready protocol: every phase has concrete commands, quantified thresholds, and genuine validation feedback loops (cache check, pre-flight gate, source-count checkpoint, citation-verification gate). The main structural weakness is that a ~290-line monolithic SKILL.md keeps everything inline — the output template and scoring rubrics are natural candidates for one-level-deep reference files — plus a dangling `--update` flag reference.
Suggestions
Move the Fase 4 output template (and optionally the two scoring tables) to references/output-template.md and references/scoring.md, keeping SKILL.md a phase-by-phase overview with clearly signaled links — this shortens the always-loaded context while keeping the details one level deep.
Define or remove the `--update` flag: the output template says "Re-pesquisar com `--update` após 7 dias" but neither the argument-hint nor Fase 0 describes it; either add it to the argument-hint and Fase 0 behavior, or drop the mention.
Give an executable age check for the cache (e.g. `find memory/research -name '<slug>.md' -mtime -7`) so the <7-day rule in Fase 0 is machine-checkable rather than implied.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense operational protocol — commands, scoring tables, ledger schema, output template — with almost no explanation of concepts Claude already knows. Minor trimmable material exists: the multi-repository attribution paragraph in the intro quote, and the Anti-padrões section which restates rules already given in Fases 0, 3 and 3.5 (e.g. "Guardar fontes com score < 4.0" and "Re-pesquisar sem checar cache"). This lands on anchor 4 (efficient, minor instances that could be trimmed) rather than 5 because of that redundancy. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is largely copy-paste ready: concrete `gh search repos/issues` commands with --json field lists, `site:` query templates, an explicit weighted formula "(oficial×0.4) + (recência×0.3) + (profundidade×0.2) + (comunidade×0.1)" with a 4.0 cutoff, a jsonl ledger example, and a complete output template. It stops short of anchor 5 due to small gaps: the output template references a `--update` flag that the argument-hint and protocol never define, and the <7-day cache check gives `ls memory/research/` but no command for checking file age. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Phases 0→1→1.5→2→3→3.5→4 are clearly sequenced with explicit validation checkpoints and feedback loops: the cache check (Fase 0), the pre-flight query-quality gate before spending search budget (Fase 1.5), the checkpoint "se restarem menos de 3 fontes acima de 4.0 ... voltar e ampliar a busca", and the Fase 3.5 citation-verification gate that routes unsupported claims to "Gaps Identificados". This matches anchor 5 (clear sequence, explicit validation, error-recovery loops); the only blemish — two sections both numbered "Fase 3" — is labeling, not sequencing. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The bundle contains no references/, scripts/ or assets/ — everything (~290 lines) is inlined in SKILL.md, including a ~60-line output template and two full scoring-rubric tables that could live in one-level-deep reference files. Structure within the file is good (clear headers per phase), which puts it above anchor 2, but there is no overview-to-detail layering at all, matching anchor 3 ("some structure ... content that should be separate is inline"); it is not 4 because nothing is split out despite the length. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |