Content
62%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers an exceptionally clear, well-validated TDD workflow with strong feedback loops and anti-rationalization guardrails — the process guidance is among the most actionable of its kind. Its weaknesses are verbosity (duplicated checklists and an XP tangent re-explaining known concepts) and a monolithic structure whose referenced deep-dive files are absent from the bundle.
Suggestions
Cut the 'XP' section to a short pointer list mapping each practice to its policy file, and merge the near-duplicate 'Saidas Esperadas', 'Evidencia de Conclusao', and 'Checklist Por Ciclo' checklists into one — roughly 60-80 lines could be removed without losing any actionable guidance.
Trim the 'Filosofia' section: Claude already knows what good vs. bad tests are; keep only the kit-specific rules (no internal-collaborator mocks, no private-method tests, spec-reading names).
Create the referenced docs/skill-guides/*.md files (or remove the dangling references, including tdd-deep-modules.md which is marked 'a criar conforme demanda') so the 'Material Adicional' pointers resolve within the bundle.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | At ~240 lines the body contains several padded sections explaining concepts Claude already knows: the 'Filosofia' section re-explains what good vs. bad tests are, and the ~15-line 'XP' section explains pair programming, CI, sustainable pace, and YAGNI before mapping them to kit policies. Content is also repeated nearly verbatim across 'Saidas Esperadas', 'Evidencia de Conclusao', and 'Checklist Por Ciclo' (e.g., 'nenhum teste mocka colaborador interno', 'testes leem como spec'). This matches anchor 2 ('noticeably verbose; several unnecessary explanations or padded sections') rather than 3, because the padding and duplication go beyond occasional tightening opportunities — though the core workflow sections themselves are tight and imperative, keeping it above anchor 1's severe padding. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | For an instruction-only process skill, the guidance is concrete and specific: explicit RED→GREEN loop patterns, a planning checklist with the exact key question to ask, hard rules ('Nunca refactore enquanto RED', 'um teste por vez', 'so codigo suficiente para passar o teste atual'), and a decision procedure for broken tests after refactor. It falls short of anchor 5 only in minor gaps — e.g., no concrete example of a test name/file layout beyond the 'user can X when Y' pattern — and is clearly above anchor 3, where guidance would be pseudocode-level or missing key details. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The process is explicitly sequenced (Fase 1 Planning → Fase 2 Tracer Bullet → Fase 3 Loop Incremental → Fase 4 Refactor) with validation at each step: verify the RED failure demonstrates the missing behavior, run tests after each refactor step, a per-cycle checklist, and an 'Evidencia de Conclusao' gate. Error-recovery feedback loops are spelled out ('Se um refactor quebrar um teste que passava: investigue regressao... Corrija ou reverta'), plus an anti-rationalization table for failure modes. This matches anchor 5's 'clear sequence with explicit validation steps; feedback loops for error recovery; checklists for complex processes'; anchor 4 would require missing or merely implicit checkpoints, which is not the case. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The SKILL.md is monolithic — no references/, scripts/, or assets/ bundle exists, and the files it points to (docs/skill-guides/tdd-approved-fixtures.md, tdd-mocking.md, tdd-refactoring.md, architecture-and-evidence.md) are not present in the bundle, with tdd-deep-modules.md even marked 'a criar conforme demanda'. References are clearly signaled one level deep in 'Material Adicional', and in-section headers are decent, but self-contained content that could live in separate files (the XP essay, interface heuristics, the full anti-rationalization table) is inlined, and several pointers are dangling. This sits at anchor 3 ('some structure; references present but content that should be separate is inline') — above anchor 2 because navigation within the file is real and references are not buried, below anchor 4 because the referenced files largely don't exist in the bundle. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |