Content
61%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
Well-organized, checklist-driven content with a clean structure and mostly efficient token use, undermined by one material defect: the bundled analyzer script depends on ../../lib/shared.js, which is absent, so the skill's primary command crashes when run. The workflow also lacks a remediation/re-verification loop after warnings.
Suggestions
Fix the broken dependency: scripts/change_analyzer.js requires ../../lib/shared.js which is not in the bundle — vendor the shared helpers into the script (or ship lib/shared.js inside the skill) so "node scripts/change_analyzer.js" actually executes.
Add an explicit feedback loop to the 校验流程: when the analyzer reports ⚠️ (e.g., DESIGN.md not updated), instruct Claude to remediate and re-run the analyzer to confirm the warning clears before concluding 可提交.
Provide a fallback for when the script fails or the environment lacks Node/git (e.g., manual `git diff --stat` checks), so the verification workflow does not dead-end at step 1.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and instruction-shaped — tables ("代码变更 > 50 行但 DESIGN.md 未更新"), checklists, commands, and templates with almost no concept explanation. The main trimmable fluff is the aphoristic 核心原则 block ("无理由的变更是隐患,无记录的变更是灾难…"), which is philosophical padding with no instructional value — a minor instance of over-explanation, fitting anchor 4 rather than 3 (the rest is efficient) or 5 (the padding exists). | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Commands are concrete and flags verified ("node scripts/change_analyzer.js --mode staged / -v / --json" all match the script's parser), and thresholds/checklists are specific — but the headline command fails at runtime: change_analyzer.js requires '../../lib/shared.js', which is not in the bundle, so "node scripts/change_analyzer.js" crashes with 'Cannot find module'. The core automated guidance is therefore not executable as shipped, matching anchor 3 (concrete but incomplete, key details missing) rather than 4 (minor gaps). | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The 校验流程 lists a clear 5-step sequence and the 前置/后置检查 checklists act as checkpoints, but there is no feedback loop — nothing says what to do when the analyzer emits a ⚠️ warning (update docs, then re-run to confirm it clears) or when the script itself fails — and the verification step depends on the broken script. Anchor 3 (sequence present, validation gaps / remediation implicit) fits better than 4, which would require most checkpoints to be functional and complete. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The analysis logic is properly externalized into a real bundle file referenced by exact path ("node scripts/change_analyzer.js", verified to exist with matching modes), and sections are clearly headed and scannable. It is not 5: at ~125 lines, content like the 变更记录格式 and 校验报告格式 templates could live in reference files, and the only bundle reference is embedded in a bash block rather than clearly signaled as a navigable reference. Well above anchor 3 (nothing is buried, structure is good). | 4 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |