Content
75%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-structured, lean instruction-only skill: concrete file paths, ID conventions, required fields, and a clearly sequenced process with hard constraints. It falls short of top marks mainly on the absence of a worked example and a final validation checkpoint, plus minor duplication between the Process and Output Format sections.
Suggestions
Add one filled-in example FR (e.g., FR-001 with Title, Description, actor, preconditions, success/failure, priority) so the output format is copy-paste unambiguous.
Add a final verification step to the Process, e.g. 'Before writing files, re-check every FR is atomic and testable; any gap becomes an OQ' — this supplies the missing feedback loop.
Either bundle the named template files under references/ or rephrase 'Use templates:' to 'Structure each output file as follows' so no phantom files are implied.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and skill-specific with no explanations of concepts Claude already knows, but there is minor redundancy: the FR field list appears in both Step 2 and the Output Format section, and the no-invention rule is stated in the Extraction Rules as well as implied by 'Explicit Unknowns' framing. Not a 5 because those duplications could be trimmed. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete guidance throughout: canonical output paths (spec/10-requirements/functional-requirements.md, spec/99-meta/open-questions.md, spec/99-meta/assumptions.md), ID schemes (FR-001, OQ-001, A-001, CAP-<name>), required FR fields, and priority values (P0/P1/P2 or UNKNOWN). Not a 5 because there is no worked example of a complete FR or Open Question, and 'Use templates: functional-requirements.md' references template files that are not bundled, leaving slight ambiguity. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Steps 0-5 are clearly sequenced (intake summary, actors, FRs, capability grouping, unknowns, assumptions) and the Extraction Rules act as an inline checklist; the UNKNOWN fallback ('mark UNKNOWN + add an Open Question') handles the main error path. Not a 5 because there is no final verification step or feedback loop (e.g., confirm every FR is testable and atomic before writing the output files). | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Sections are well organized and all content is appropriately inline for a self-contained ~64-line skill with no bundle files. Not a 5 because the body is marginally over the under-50-line simple-skill threshold, and the 'Use templates:' line names files (functional-requirements.md, open-questions.md, assumptions.md) without bundling them or signaling paths, slightly muddying navigation. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |