Content
77%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A tightly written, highly operational orchestration skill: exact CLI commands, explicit gates, exit-code handling, and a genuine validate-fix-recheck loop. Its main defect is that the bundle does not back its own references — nearly every `resources/` file the workflow depends on (intent routing, output laws, frameworks, checklist) is absent from the shipped files.
Suggestions
Ship or fix the `resources/` files: the body depends on `resources/intent-rules.md`, `resources/output-laws.md`, `resources/frameworks/{swot,porters-5f,pestel}.md`, `resources/checklist.md`, `resources/error-playbook.md`, and `resources/execution-protocol.md`, but none exist in the bundle (only `references/_shared/runtime/route-selection.md` is present). Either add them under `references/` and update the paths, or inline the minimal content (e.g., the intent classification table) that the skill cannot run without.
Make the example bash block self-contained: define `$QUERY_PLAN_FILE` (or show how the Step 0.75 query plan is written to a file) and replace the `# … upstream Steps 0 / 0.45 …` placeholder with a one-line pointer to where those steps begin in the upstream contract, so the example is copy-paste runnable.
Trim the duplication between Dependencies and the Canonical command path (resolve/update behavior is described twice) and merge the overlapping 'Intent signature' and 'When to use' bullets to save tokens without losing information.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and operational throughout — it never explains concepts Claude already knows (no 'what is Reddit/SWOT' padding) and assumes competence. Minor redundancy keeps it from a 5: the Dependencies section re-describes `oma market resolve`/`oma market update` behavior that steps 2 and the failure section already cover, and 'Intent signature' overlaps 'When to use'. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | The 8-step canonical path gives exact, executable commands with exit-code semantics (`oma market detect-trap "<topic>"`, `oma market resolve --json`, `oma market run <args> --emit=compact`) plus concrete output paths. Not a 5 because the example bash block references an undefined `$QUERY_PLAN_FILE` variable and a `# … upstream Steps …` placeholder, so it is not fully copy-paste ready. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The sequence is explicit with real validation checkpoints and feedback loops: detect-trap preflight (exit 2 → REFUSE, stop), resolve gate (ok:false → stop with reason), and step 8's 'run the self-check … fix and re-check' loop, backed by a dedicated Failure and recovery section. This matches the top anchor; it is above 4 because checkpoints are explicit rather than implicit, and the operation is not destructive so no cap applies. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The References section is well-signaled with one-level-deep pointers and load hints ('load only the selected framework'), but scored against the actual bundle: of the eight referenced paths, only `references/_shared/runtime/route-selection.md` exists — `resources/intent-rules.md`, `resources/output-laws.md`, `resources/frameworks/*.md`, `resources/checklist.md`, `resources/error-playbook.md`, and `resources/execution-protocol.md` are all missing. Navigation that dangles for 7 of 8 targets is more than the 'minor organization gaps' of the 4 anchor, but the clear signaling keeps it above the muddled structure of 2. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |