Content
81%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An unusually actionable and well-sequenced operational manual: every phase has executable gbrain commands, explicit validation checkpoints, error-recovery guidance, and a machine-readable report format. The main costs are token weight — a duplicated report template, repeated gate statements, and an inline version-anchored changelog — in an otherwise clean single-file structure with well-signaled cross-skill references.
Suggestions
Delete the duplicate report template: the Phase 7 section and the Output Format section repeat nearly the same '## EIIRP Complete' block — keep one and cross-reference it.
Move the Changelog (and its version-pinned details like 'v0.39 cathedral', 'v0.19 resolver') into a CHANGELOG.md reference file or trim it to one line per version, keeping SKILL.md free of time-sensitive version detail.
Consolidate the auto-fire gate rule, currently restated in the Contract, the gate section, Anti-Patterns, and Hard Rules, into the gate section with one-line pointers from the other three.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly procedural and command-driven, but carries real fat: the Phase 7 report template appears twice nearly verbatim ("## EIIRP Complete: [Topic]" in Phase 7 and again in Output Format), the auto-fire gate rule is restated four-plus times (Contract, gate section, Anti-Patterns, Hard Rules), and a changelog with version-specific detail ("gbrain v0.39.0.0", "the v0.19 resolver") pads the tail. Not 2 because there is no explaining of concepts Claude already knows and most sections earn their tokens; not 4 because the duplication and changelog bulk are more than minor. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Every phase ships copy-paste-ready commands: "gbrain schema show --json", "gbrain capture --file <analysis.md> --slug <taxonomist-path>", "gbrain schema review-candidates --apply <prefix-or-type-name>", "gbrain check-resolvable", plus concrete templates (manifest, filing-plan table, Phase 7 report) and explicit thresholds like "confidence < 0.6... DO NOT auto-apply". Fully executable with specific examples covering the common cases. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The 7 phases are clearly sequenced with a dedicated verification phase (Phase 6 checklist: "All brain pages have proper frontmatter", "gbrain orphans — any pages without inbound links?"), mid-flow validation (Phase 4c "Verify every link resolves"), a human-in-the-loop confidence gate in Phase 3, and explicit error-recovery loops in "When it fails" ("revision_conflict or write_pending (exit 10): re-read and merge, or poll gbrain write-request <request_id>"). Batch brain-writes are fully covered by validation, so no cap applies. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | No bundle files exist (references/, scripts/, assets/ all absent), so all content is inline, but the single file is well-organized with numbered phase sections, checklists, and clearly signaled one-level-deep cross-skill references ("skills/brain-taxonomist/SKILL.md", "../conventions/brain-first.md", "skills/meeting-ingestion/SKILL.md") that all resolve as named sibling skills. Not 5 because ~460 lines of changelog, gate policy detail, and the duplicated report template are inlined in SKILL.md where a reference file split would ease navigation; not 3 because references that do exist are clearly signaled and the structure is consistently good. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |