Content
85%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is highly actionable and safe: complete executable examples, exact CLI commands, an explicit verification checklist, permission gating, and strong failure-mode recovery. Its main weakness is structure — a single ~765-line file with no local reference files, inlining publishing and theming detail that belongs in separate reference documents.
Suggestions
Split the ~765-line body: keep the contribution routing table, project setup, and verification checklist in SKILL.md, and move the publishing/OVERVIEW.md contract, theme contribution, and full composer-pill example into references/ files (e.g., references/publishing.md, references/themes.md) linked one level deep.
Trim inline policy prose such as the OVERVIEW.md authoring contract and host-picker behavior down to the actionable rules, pointing to the publishing guide for the full content contract.
Add explicit validation output expectations for the mobile audit (e.g., what a hit in client/web.ts versus elsewhere looks like) so the rg-based check is self-verifying.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and imperative throughout — it never explains concepts Claude already knows (React, npm, semver basics) and every section carries Paseo-specific contract details. Minor over-explanation remains, e.g., the multi-paragraph OVERVIEW.md authoring contract ("Use sentence case and plain factual language, with no em dashes. Omit installation commands, badges...") and the host-picker paragraph, which could be trimmed or moved. It fits the 4 anchor (efficient with minor trimmable instances) rather than 5, and is clearly above the 3 anchor's 'some unnecessary explanation'. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is fully executable: complete copy-paste TSX/TS files for panels, screens, RPCs, attachment sources, and pills (e.g., the `client.addWorkspacePanel({...})` and `defineRpc({...})` examples), exact CLI invocations (`paseo plugin init /absolute/path/to/my-plugin`, `paseo plugin install npm:@acme/paseo-review@1.2.0`), a runnable audit (`rg -n "document\.|window\.|..." client/`), and a common-failures table. This matches the 5 anchor's copy-paste-ready coverage of common cases. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | "Verify the outcome" is an explicit 5-step validation checklist (typecheck → install/reload → `paseo plugin ls` requires `running` → confirm on the intended host including compact/mobile and dark theme → exercise the action and its error state), and the trust section adds a permission gate with verification (`paseo reload --json`, checking `appliedPaths`, re-checking `plugin ls`). A reload-failure feedback loop ("inspect `paseo plugin ls` ... fix the source, typecheck, and reload again") and a failures→causes table close the loop. Clear sequence with explicit validation and error recovery — the 5 anchor. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Headers, a contribution-routing table, and clearly labeled one-level-deep links to hosted docs (reference.md sections, plugin-examples repos) provide real navigation, but there are no local bundle files at all and the ~765-line body inlines content that clearly belongs in separate reference files — the full publishing/OVERVIEW.md contract, the theme section, and the complete composer-pill example. This sits between the 3 anchor (content that should be separate is inline, though structure exists) and the 4 anchor; the absence of any local reference split for this much material keeps it at 3. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |