Content
96%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A dense, highly actionable playbook: concrete engine calls, exact quotes and formats, sequenced steps with hard rules, approval gates, validation checkpoints and error-recovery loops, and no wasted tokens. The only material weakness is that several step-critical references (the atoms/*.ATOM.md sub-playbooks and the ../../../skills/marketing/* gate skills) are not present in the bundle, leaving parts of the navigation dangling.
Suggestions
Bundle the three atoms/ sub-playbooks cited in Steps 2, 4 and 7 (source-audit, shot-list, fidelity-check), or inline their core procedures into those steps — they are the operational core of those steps but no such files exist in the skill bundle.
Resolve the dangling ../../../skills/marketing/* cross-references (claims-gate, spend-gate, honest-review, save-learning, save-to-brain): either ship those gate skills in the bundle or inline the one-line rule each gate needs, so every relative path cited in the body exists.
Add a short bundle map (one line per file: which file owns which step) near the top of the body so navigation across SKILL.md, the three references/ files and the atoms sub-playbooks is fully self-describing.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is telegraphic and rule-dense with no filler: every line is a tool call, decision rule, or gate (e.g. "a re-shoot is quoted again, with the engine's suggested_control_change offered"), and it never explains concepts Claude already knows. Not 4: there is no over-explanation or padding to trim — parentheticals like the generator-filename list are operational detection heuristics, not digressions. | 5 / 5 |
Actionability | Every step carries concrete executable guidance: exact tool calls with parameters ("gooseworks:photos_generate dry_run: true", "brand_read lean (sections: [\"summary\",\"kit\",\"products\",\"learnings\"])"), verbatim reply strings ("Connect GooseWorks first — I make your product photos through it."), and exact write-back formats ("Product imagery ready: <photo links> · <YYYY-MM-DD>"). Not 4: the specific examples cover the common cases end-to-end, including both host modes and failure paths. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Nine clearly sequenced steps with explicit validation checkpoints and feedback loops: the hero read-back where "a blocker, or controls the shot needed dropped, stops the run and goes to the human before the rest is spent", the fidelity check on every passed/flagged output, re-shoot re-quoting, workflow_error handling, and bounded polling with "never resubmit (it pays again)". Not 4: validation is not merely present but gated (four named approval gates, a 'Done when' zero-false-passes criterion), covering the money and batch risks. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Structure is good: the three references/ files exist and are cited by resolvable section numbers one level deep ("Load references/fit-and-honesty.md §1", "references/shot-list-and-surfaces.md §1–2", "rubric in references/fidelity-rubric.md"), and SKILL.md stays an overview. Not 5: the atoms/source-audit, atoms/shot-list and atoms/fidelity-check sub-playbooks (the operational core of Steps 2, 4 and 7) and five ../../../skills/marketing/*/SKILL.md gate references do not exist in the provided bundle, so navigation is partly dangling. Not 3: the references that do exist are clearly signaled with section anchors and the content split is appropriate. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 19 / 20 Passed |