Content
60%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A dense, highly actionable operational workflow with genuine validation checkpoints and a well-designed error-recovery feedback loop, undermined by a broken progressive-disclosure design — all Liquibase generation rules live in a reference.md that is not shipped — and by notable repetition across the Important Rules, gate-protocol, and error-recovery sections. Tightening the duplication and shipping the missing reference file would lift it substantially.
Suggestions
Ship reference.md in the skill bundle (or inline the essential Liquibase YAML rules): the body defers all generation rules, FK column resolution, and error-recovery root causes to a file that does not exist, breaking Step 4, 3-B-4, and Error Recovery step 2.
Deduplicate repeated instructions — the verbatim-error/openInHarness rules appear in Steps D, E, F, and Important Rules, and failure classification appears in both Step F triage and Error Recovery step 1a; state each once and reference it.
Standardize step numbering and heading levels ("### Step 4" vs "## Step 5", the "Steps A–E" reference, nested 3-B) and document the source of unresolved placeholders like <org_id>, <project_id>, and <account>.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly operational, domain-specific instruction (MCP resource calls, gate protocol, engine-prefix table) that Claude could not know, but it is noticeably repetitive: "surface the exact error message verbatim and stop / Do NOT fabricate navigation paths / never construct the URL manually" appears in Steps D, E, F, and Important Rules; the accept/deny/accept-commit rules and conversation_id resolution are stated twice; and the infrastructure-vs-changeset failure classification is duplicated between Step F triage and Error Recovery step 1a. Anchor 3 ("could be tightened") fits better than 4, where the duplication is more than minor. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete, near-copy-paste tool calls with exact args (harness_list/harness_get/harness_execute blocks), deterministic reply strings, decision tables, and worked author-normalization examples make this largely executable. Not 5, because some placeholders are never resolved (where do `<org_id>`, `<project_id>`, `<account>` come from?), and Step C's elicitation loop is currently superseded by the server-side "stop and tell the user" note, leaving the documented loop unexecutable as written. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Sequencing is clear (Step 0 context check → discovery → engine resolution → snapshot checks → generation → HITL review gate → accept/deny/commit branches) with explicit validation checkpoints (conflict check in 3-B-2, the mandatory Accept/Deny review, error-recovery feedback loop with failure classification). Not 5, because of labeling drift ("### Step 4" vs "## Step 5", a gate-protocol reference to "Steps A–E" vs the actual A–F, nested 3-B) and because Step 4's execution path depends entirely on a reference.md that is absent from the bundle, leaving a gap in the otherwise well-validated workflow. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The body repeatedly defers bulk detail to a single one-level-deep reference ("Before generating Liquibase YAML, Read `reference.md`... It contains all Liquibase YAML rules"), but no reference.md exists in the bundle — references/, scripts/, and assets/ are all absent, so every reference to it (Step 4, 3-B-4, Error Recovery step 2) is dangling and the disclosed content is simply missing. Per the bundle-structure guideline this is worse than the anchor-3 case of merely unclear references; the claimed disclosure layer does not exist, matching anchor 2's "minimal structure" failure. | 2 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |