Content
88%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-engineered operational skill: concrete commands, an explicit validated workflow with read-back verification and honest-reporting rules, and disciplined offloading of detail to references. The main defects are redundant restatement of a few policies and bundle hygiene: a broken SKILL.en.md redirect and orphaned bundle files.
Suggestions
Add SKILL.en.md to the bundle (or remove the English redirect) — English-language requests are currently directed to a file that does not exist, dead-ending the very first body instruction.
Reference references/cv-dl-terminology.md and assets/reorganize_notes.py from the relevant sections (e.g. concept maintenance and note organization) or remove them, so the 18KB terminology file is discoverable when needed.
Consolidate the save/no-fake-save/critique-delivery policies into one authoritative section and reference it from §4/§6/§7 instead of restating each rule three times.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and prescriptive with no explanations of concepts Claude already knows (no 'what is Obsidian/arXiv' padding), and every section carries task-specific rules. Not 5 because key policies repeat ~3× each (no-asking-to-save in 默认执行约定/§4/§7, no-fake-save in 默认执行约定/§4/§7, critique-mandatory in §3/§6/§7), and a few overloaded run-on paragraphs (e.g. the version-handling and Git paragraphs) could be tightened. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable guidance throughout: concrete commands with defined variables (`python3 ../_shared/user_config.py`, `python3 assets/zotero_helper.py info {item_id}`, WebFetch `https://arxiv.org/html/{arxiv_id}`, `pdfimages -png`, `git -C "{VAULT_PATH}" rev-parse --show-toplevel`), a real YAML frontmatter template, a mode/trigger/output table, and correct-vs-incorrect URL-concatenation examples for the known arXiv image bug. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Steps 0–8 are clearly sequenced with explicit validation: write-then-read-back verification of saved notes ("未写入成功不能报告'已保存'"), the mandatory URL dedup check before writing, the §6 merged self-check checklist, the A→B→C image fallback with post-save reachability repair, and honest per-stage reporting ("同步失败不能把本地 commit 报告为 push 成功"). Batch processing (§8) inherits per-paper validation via dedup and existing-note checks. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Good structure: point-of-use references plus a terminal '参考文件（按需查阅）' section with one-line descriptions; all four named reference files exist and are one level deep. Not 5 because SKILL.en.md — the first instruction English requests are redirected to — is missing from the bundle, and references/cv-dl-terminology.md (the largest reference file) and assets/reorganize_notes.py are never referenced anywhere in the body, leaving them undiscoverable. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 18 / 20 Passed |