Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A highly actionable, CLI-specific reference with excellent executable commands, error-handling tables, and a validation gate — but it is a repetitive 670-line monolith. Duplicating the Path B/C sections, restating the checkbox and protection rules several times, and inlining the MERGEFIELD patterns and K1–K19 known-issues table instead of splitting them into reference files are the main quality costs.
Suggestions
Consolidate the repeated rules: state the checkbox→formfield routing and 'protection=forms' semantics once each, and merge the 'Three Paths' Path B/C subsections with the later dedicated 'Path B — raw-set recipes' / 'Path C — Word template workflow' sections, which currently duplicate each other.
Split deep-dive material into one-level-deep reference files (e.g. references/known-issues.md for K1–K19, references/mergefield.md for the field-pattern table, references/block-level-lock.md for the Python paraId-extraction recipe) and keep SKILL.md as the overview with quick start and paths.
Close the Delivery Gate gaps: the 'hard floor' promises executable checks for all 10 requirements, but formfield name ≤ 20 chars, non-empty dropdown items, intended date format, and lock readback have no gate — add jq checks for these or reword the claim.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly high-value CLI-specific detail (exact traps, error strings, known issues) rather than explanations of known concepts, but noticeably repetitive across sections: the checkbox-is-formfield-not-SDT rule is stated ~5 times, 'protection=forms' semantics 3 times, and the Path B raw-set and Path C template workflows each appear twice (in 'Three Paths' and again as dedicated sections). Matches the score-3 anchor ('mostly efficient but could be tightened'); not 2 because the padding is repetition of genuinely non-obvious CLI facts, not generic filler, and not 4 because the duplication is substantial rather than minor. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable throughout: copy-paste bash blocks with exact paths ('officecli add "$FILE" /body --type sdt --prop type=dropdown --prop items="Engineering,Finance,HR"'), exact xpaths for raw-set, literal error messages with fixes ('raw-set: 0 element(s) affected' → symptom/fix table), and a runnable Delivery Gate script. Specific examples cover the common cases (intake form, SOW, checkbox, mail-merge); matches the score-5 anchor. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Clear sequencing with strong feedback loops: an explicit build order ('create+open → metadata → structure → ... → protection=forms LAST → close'), sequenced sow-a/b/c recipes, UNSUPPORTED/VALIDATION stop-and-fix rules, and an executable 6-gate Delivery Gate with REJECT handling. Not 5 because the 'Requirements for Outputs (hard floor)' claims 'Delivery Gate enforces each as an executable check', but the gate script only covers ~6 of the 10 requirements — e.g. formfield name ≤ 20 chars and non-empty dropdown items have no gate check, leaving a minor validation gap. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | No bundle files exist (no references/, scripts/, or assets/), so all ~670 lines live in SKILL.md under one level. Section headers are clear and there are no nested/dead references, but material that clearly belongs in separate reference files is inlined: the MERGEFIELD field-pattern table, raw-set recipes B1–B3, the K1–K19 Known Issues table, and the block-level-lock Python recipe. Matches the score-3 anchor ('some structure ... content that should be separate is inline'); not 2 because headers make the monolith navigable, not 4 because the deep-dive bulk is unsplit. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |