Content
42%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is an elaborate Lean 4 formal contract whose doc comments carry the real instructions, wrapped by a thin layer of directly actionable sections (Mode Activation, Protocol, Intensity, Rules). The actionable guidance that exists is specific, but it is buried in heavily redundant formal prose with no worked example, and the monolithic inline block defeats progressive disclosure despite the one well-signaled reference file.
Suggestions
Move the bulk of the Lean contract into a reference file (e.g. references/contract.md) and keep in SKILL.md a one-screen operational core — the surface/read/resolve loop, the Intensity table, and the Rules — loading the formal block only when the occasion calls for it.
Deduplicate the four restatements of the flow (FLOW comment, MORPHISM, elicit definition, TOOL GROUNDING) into a single canonical sequence, and compress the long single-paragraph doc comments on StandingSupported, Reaches, and coordinates to their carve-out lists.
Add one worked example — a short seed utterance, the first surface composed per the surface entry, and one answer changing the record — so the axiom-level rules are grounded in an executable demonstration.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Roughly 340 of the ~385 body lines are a single Lean 4 block whose doc comments restate the same distinctions several times over — the surface flow is described independently in the FLOW comment, the MORPHISM comment, the elicit/start definitions, the TOOL GROUNDING surface entry, and again in Rules ("Round composition", "Focus and record"). Long single-paragraph doc comments (e.g. StandingSupported, Reaches) repeat the same carve-outs multiple ways. This is noticeably verbose with several padded sections (anchor 2); it avoids anchor 1 only because the protocol is novel rather than re-explaining concepts Claude already knows. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | There is real concrete guidance: the TOOL GROUNDING surface entry specifies exactly what each surface presents ("a one-sentence read-back of the intent as understood... each open coordinate the round shows, with its question, where it comes from... your contrary grounds before the questions"), the Intensity table maps levels to formats, and Mode Activation lists explicit skip conditions. But the actionable core is buried in a formal contract where every operative judgment (aporia, coordinates, StandingSupported, operative, Reaches) is an axiom black box, and no worked example of a surface or exchange is given — some concrete guidance, incomplete in specifics, matching anchor 3. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The sequence exists — detect → surface → readAnswer → converge → seam — and is even implemented structurally in the elicit recursion with explicit branches ([the utterance does not bear on this run] / [aligned enough] / [otherwise]), and the LOOP and CONVERGENCE sections state feedback behavior ("every surface is dialogue", "Demonstrated, not asserted"). However the operational sequence must be reconstructed from four scattered restatements rather than read as one coherent flow, and checkpoints like convergence evidence are implicit rather than step-anchored — sequence present with implicit checkpoints, matching anchor 3 rather than the mostly-checkpointed anchor 4. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The one bundle reference (references/round-composition.md) is well done: it exists, is one level deep with no nested references, and is conditionally loaded under clearly stated occasions ("when a term must remain stable across the session, wording must travel unchanged, or material belongs to another round or trace") — that part sits at anchor 4-5 quality. But the SKILL.md itself inlines a ~340-line formal block whose reading-guidance preamble targets a specialist reader, while the actionable sections (Protocol, Intensity, Rules) total ~40 lines — content that arguably belongs in a separate contract file is inlined monolithically, matching anchor 3's 'content that should be separate is inline'. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 11 / 20 Passed |