Content
42%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body specifies an unusually rigorous and internally consistent dialogical protocol with a genuinely well-signaled reference file, but it is severely overweight: a ~550-line Lean formal block inlined in SKILL.md, duplicated between its doc comments and the Protocol prose, with no worked example of the sheet it mandates and no consolidated step-by-step procedure. The structure is recoverable only with substantial inference effort.
Suggestions
Move the Lean formal block to a reference file (e.g. references/contract.md) and keep in SKILL.md a short summary of the judgments it fixes, cutting the duplication between the block's doc comments and the Protocol prose.
Add one compact worked example — a mini sheet with goal, working candidate, one cross-view row, and the move — so the mandated deliverable's format is unambiguous without inferring it from axiom annotations.
Consolidate the activation → sheet → response → recognition sequence into a short numbered procedure in the Protocol section, surfacing `notActivated`, `Overturned`, and the closing judgment as explicit checkpoints.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~600-line body carries a ~550-line Lean 4 block whose doc comments are restated nearly verbatim in the Protocol prose (e.g. "A reading you would no longer hold stays in the cross view until the user sets it aside" appears in the `readings` axiom and again in the sheet section), and the prose's long nested em-dash clauses force re-reading. This is noticeably verbose with duplicated sections rather than severely padded explanation of known concepts, matching anchor 2 rather than 1 or 3. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | The sheet deliverable is concretely structured ("Each sheet opens with any case you found... Then the goal... Then the cross view, one row per live reading... Then a cases section"), giving real guidance for an instruction-only skill, but there is no worked example or template of a sheet, and operational rules are buried as formal `axiom` annotations the practitioner must infer from. Some concrete but incomplete guidance matches anchor 3 rather than 4 (a key executable detail — what a sheet looks like — is missing). | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A sequence exists (the FLOW comment's start → notActivated → sheet → per-utterance branches) and checkpoints exist as formal readings (`notActivated`, `Overturned`, `ClosingSupported`), but the operational sequence is scattered across the Lean comment block, Mode Activation, and Protocol sections with no consolidated step list, leaving checkpoints implicit for the practitioner. Anchor 3 fits: steps are present but the reader must reconstruct the ordered procedure and its verification points. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | One well-signaled, one-level-deep reference exists with explicit load conditions ("Read `references/round-composition.md` before composing when terminology must remain stable..."), which is good practice, but the ~550-line formal contract is inlined wholesale in SKILL.md where an overview plus a reference file would serve. Some structure with clear signaling but bulk content inline matches anchor 3 rather than 4 (the monolithic inline block is a major organization gap) or 2 (the reference is present, clearly signaled, and shallow). | 3 / 5 |
Total | 11 / 20 Passed |