Content
35%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An ambitious formal protocol whose body buries a workable workflow (relay spec → build placeholder probes → present contrast map → person closes → harvest → verified discard) under extreme abstraction and fourfold redundancy, with a ~450-line Lean contract inlined in the SKILL.md. The one reference file is well used, but the skill offers almost no concrete, executable material — no example probe, map, or round — leaving the reader to reverse-engineer the practice from the specification.
Suggestions
Add one worked example — a sample vignette probe's narration text, a small rendered contrast map with per-cell footing, and one composed round — so the protocol becomes executable guidance instead of a specification to interpret (addresses actionability).
State the workflow exactly once as a short numbered sequence in plain language, and delete the repeated restatements across FLOW, MORPHISM, PHASE TRANSITIONS, LOOP, and the specRelay/present entries; trim the `.present` entry to its decision rules (addresses conciseness).
Move the full Lean contract to a bundle file such as `references/contract.md`, loaded on demand the way `round-composition.md` already is, and keep SKILL.md as a lean overview with the core principle and step sequence (addresses progressive_disclosure and conciseness).
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~500-line body restates the same workflow at least four times (FLOW, MORPHISM, PHASE TRANSITIONS/LOOP, and TOOL GROUNDING's specRelay/present entries), and the `.present` entry alone is a several-hundred-word wall of nested clauses. It does not pad with concepts Claude already knows, which keeps it above anchor 1, but the redundancy and density are far past 'could be tightened' (anchor 3) — 'noticeably verbose; several unnecessary... padded sections' fits. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | For an instruction-only skill the guidance is overwhelmingly abstract: 'Expose direction unknowns through divergent-discard instantiation before commitment' and a Lean specification whose 'axioms' are declared model judgments. There are no concrete examples of a probe narration, a rendered contrast map, or a composed round, so Claude receives high-level structure without the specific steps or material to execute — matching 'minimal concrete guidance; high-level hints but missing the specific steps'. It is above anchor 1 only because the operation list and ordering constraints give some real structure. | 2 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A sequence does exist (gather → relay_spec → instantiate → present → fuse → constitute → harvest → cleanup → assemble) with real checkpoints — cleanupVerify verifies absence, the harvest must be read before discard, and unclear closings are handled explicitly. But the sequence is scattered across four restatements in heavily obfuscated language, and there is no concrete procedure for what a practitioner actually does in a round, so 'steps listed... checkpoints' is present while clarity is compromised between anchors 3 and 4. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The single reference, `references/round-composition.md` (a real file), is genuinely well-signaled with explicit occasion-bound conditions for when to read it, and is one level deep. However, the body is dominated by a ~450-line inline Lean block that is the kind of contract detail a SKILL.md overview should point to rather than inline, so the structure is only 'some' — above the minimal-structure anchor (2) thanks to the reference, below 'most content appropriately placed' (4). | 3 / 5 |
Total | 10 / 20 Passed |