Content
81%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An exceptionally actionable, validation-heavy orchestration spec: every step has exact commands, schemas, budgets, and error-recovery paths, and the bundle files it cites are real and well-integrated. Its weaknesses are redundancy — the same invariants (non-empty exit, advisory-not-gate, label-sweep rationale) restated in four to six places — plus one dangling reference and content duplicated between SKILL.md and assets/panel-mode.md.
Suggestions
Consolidate the spawn-and-forget / non-empty-exit warning, currently stated in 'Architecture invariants', the checklist preamble, step 5, step 9, and 'Gotchas', into one canonical section referenced from the other locations.
Defer roster, Models, and lean/delta cap details to assets/panel-mode.md instead of restating them in SKILL.md — the duplication is a sync hazard the 'Roster invariant' gotcha itself acknowledges.
Fix or remove the dangling reference to evals/fixtures/03-panel-mode-walkthrough.md, which does not exist in the bundle.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Nearly all content is project-specific contract Claude cannot infer ("Single-writer interlock", "Synchronous fan-out -- never spawn-and-forget", gh-aw safe-output semantics), so no tokens teach known concepts. But the same warnings repeat across sections: the empty-output/background-spawn failure is restated in "Architecture invariants", the checklist preamble, step 5, step 9, and "Gotchas", and the advisory/no-verdict-label point appears ~6 times. Mostly efficient but could be tightened by consolidating; not 2 because the padding is concentrated in repeated warnings rather than pervasive unnecessary explanation. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Fully executable throughout: exact commands ("gh pr view <PR_NUMBER> --json author,reviewRequests,headRefOid", "gh pr edit --add-reviewer @me"), a runnable script invocation with flags and an example path, exact label lists ("[panel-review, panel-approved, panel-rejected]"), a literal receipt line format, concrete budgets ("< 8 KB", "65536 characters"), and copy-paste prompt contracts for every subagent spawn. Not 4 because the common cases are covered with no material gaps. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A strictly ordered 0-9 execution checklist with explicit validation checkpoints and feedback loops at every stage: acceptance gate (step 0), CODEOWNERS last-comment gate (1b), delta noop (1c), persona preflight via script (2b), schema validation with bounded re-spawn ("Maximum two re-spawn attempts") and placeholder fallback (step 4), CEO re-spawn-once on failure, and the ownership consistency gate ("re-render once. If it still contradicts, emit noop"). This matches the anchor-5 pattern of clear sequence, explicit validation, and error-recovery loops. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Bundle structure is real and well-signaled one level deep: all referenced assets exist (assets/panel-mode.md, panelist-return-schema.json, ceo-return-schema.json, recommendation-template.md, shared-brief.example.json, scripts/check_required_agents.py) and each is cited with its purpose ("Load assets/panel-mode.md before fan-out", "Shape: assets/shared-brief.example.json"). But "evals/fixtures/03-panel-mode-walkthrough.md" is referenced and absent from the bundle, and roster/Models/lean-cap/shared-brief rules are duplicated between SKILL.md and assets/panel-mode.md instead of deferred. Not 5 because of the broken reference and the inline duplication; not 3 because references are clearly signaled and most content is appropriately placed. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |