Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body delivers dense, largely executable statistical and imaging guidance with a clear decision-tree workflow and a useful pre-flight check, but token efficiency and navigation suffer from a duplicated rule section, an inline code example that calls a nonexistent function, and a partially inaccurate bundle file listing. Tightening the duplicates and reconciling the References section with the actual files would lift both the conciseness and progressive-disclosure dimensions.
Suggestions
Remove the duplicated "relative proportion → percentage" guidance: keep the CRITICAL section with its code example and delete the near-identical subsection under Answer Formatting, folding any unique phrasing (e.g., the report-both note) into the single section.
Fix the Raw Image Processing example to match the actual script API (scripts/segment_cells.py exposes count_cells_watershed and count_cells_basic, not count_cells_in_image), and correct the References listing by removing the nonexistent colony_morphometry.py and statistical_comparison.py (or adding them to the bundle).
Move the ~70 lines of tool-discovery detail (Cellpose, CellPainting, BioImage Archive, FPbase) into a references/ file (e.g., references/public_data_tools.md) with a one-line pointer per tool, and add references/troubleshooting.md to the Docs list so it is discoverable.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly efficient (terse tables, decision trees, code blocks, no explanations of basic concepts), but the "relative proportion of A to B → percentage" rule is stated twice — once as a full CRITICAL section with a code example and again as a near-duplicate subsection under Answer Formatting — and the tool-discovery sections (Cellpose, CellPainting, BioImage Archive) run long with editorial asides. This matches "mostly efficient but includes some unnecessary explanation or could be tightened" rather than anchor 4's "minor instances". | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Mostly executable guidance: concrete Phase 0 globbing code, a runnable ratio-to-percentage snippet, specific R-to-Python mappings ("scipy.stats.dunnett()", "patsy.cr(x, knots=...)") and precise answer-formatting rules ("int(round(val, -3))"). Not 5 because the raw-image example imports "count_cells_in_image" from scripts.segment_cells, a function that does not exist in the actual script (it exposes count_cells_watershed/count_cells_basic), so that example is not copy-paste ready; not 3 because the majority of guidance is concrete and executable. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Clear sequence with most checkpoints present: RULE ZERO is an explicit pre-flight check before expensive re-analysis, a decision tree routes pre-quantified vs raw-image paths and test selection, and Phase 0 prints shape/columns as a data-inspection checkpoint, with the Evidence Grading table acting as a post-hoc sanity heuristic. Minor validation gaps remain (no explicit verify step after statistical testing, e.g., checking group N or re-reading output before reporting), keeping it below anchor 5. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The main path is well signaled ("See references/statistical_analysis.md for complete implementations", references/segmentation.md, cell_counting.md, image_processing.md — all real, one level deep), but scored against the actual bundle: the References section lists two scripts that do not exist (colony_morphometry.py, statistical_comparison.py), references/troubleshooting.md is orphaned (never mentioned in SKILL.md), and ~70 lines of per-tool operational detail (Cellpose/CellPainting/BioImageArchive/FPbase) are inlined rather than split out. This is "some structure but could be better organized" rather than anchor 4's "minor organization gaps". | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |