Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-organized, information-dense pipeline document with a clearly sequenced 9-phase workflow and hard-won tool-parameter specifics throughout. The dominant weakness is that every detailed reference file it points to is missing from the bundle, making the skill's deeper guidance unexecutable as shipped.
Suggestions
Ship the five referenced files (tool-reference.md, report-template.md, integration-scoring.md, response-formats.md, use-patterns.md) in the skill bundle — the body defers all tool parameters, the report template, the confidence-score formula, and fallback strategies to them, yet none are present.
Inline the 0-100 confidence score formula and the Phase 8 quality/completeness checklist directly in SKILL.md so report finalization does not depend solely on the missing integration-scoring.md.
Trim the conceptual paragraph ('Genomic mutations → transcriptomic changes → proteomic effects... Concordance across layers strengthens the finding. Discordance reveals regulatory complexity.') and consolidate the 13-item KEY PRINCIPLES list with the phase descriptions to remove redundancy.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense and tool-focused, spending tokens on specifics Claude would not know ('disease IDs use underscore format (e.g., MONDO_0004975), NOT colon', 'identifiers are newline-separated (\n), NOT space-separated'). Minor over-explanation: the conceptual paragraph 'Genomic mutations → transcriptomic changes → proteomic effects → metabolomic consequences. Concordance across layers strengthens the finding' restates systems-biology basics, and the 13-item KEY PRINCIPLES list partly duplicates the phase sections — the score-4 anchor. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Gives concrete, executable guidance: exact tool names (OpenTargets_get_disease_id_description_by_name, STRING_get_network, ReactomeAnalysis_pathway_enrichment), exact parameters and formats ('use efo_id for precision, not free-text disease_trait', 'libs must be array', 'pageSize is REQUIRED'), and concrete quantities ('top 10-15 genes'). Not 5 because copy-paste-ready call shapes and per-phase workflows are deferred entirely to tool-reference.md, which is not in the bundle. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Nine phases are clearly sequenced with explicit checkpoints ('Phase 0: Disease Disambiguation (ALWAYS FIRST)', 'If ambiguous, present top 3-5 options and ask user to select', Phase 8 'verify completeness'). Not 5 because the validation mechanics, quality checklist, and confidence-score formula are delegated to integration-scoring.md, which is absent from the bundle, leaving the error-recovery loops unreachable. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | SKILL.md itself is well structured with a clear reference table and one-level-deep pointers ('All detailed content is in reference files in this directory'), but none of the five cited files (tool-reference.md, report-template.md, integration-scoring.md, response-formats.md, use-patterns.md) exist in the bundle, so all detailed content is unreachable. Per the rubric's instruction to score against the actual bundle structure, this sits between the clearly-signaled-but-minor-gap level (4) and disorganized references (3). | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |