Content
67%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-structured dispatcher skill: a clearly sequenced 0-8 workflow with audit validation, feedback loops, and confirmation gates, plus concrete paths and commands throughout. Its main weaknesses are redundancy (the pre-flight template block, critical_rules, and success criteria repeat process content) and reliance on engine-placeholder file references that cannot be verified from the bundle.
Suggestions
Remove the duplicated Pre-flight Check markdown block in step 0 (or the bullets above it) — one of the two presentations is sufficient and would trim ~15 lines.
Consolidate critical_rules entries that merely restate process steps ("Archive before deleting", "One-line summary") into the steps themselves, keeping critical_rules for genuinely new constraints only.
Add an explicit verification step after archiving (e.g., confirm both milestone archive files exist and are non-empty before deleting .planning/REQUIREMENTS.md) to close the destructive-operation validation gap.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | Mostly efficient, but the 17-line Pre-flight Check markdown block in step 0 restates the four bullets directly above it, the critical_rules section echoes process steps ("Archive before deleting", "One-line summary"), and success_criteria restate step outcomes. Fits anchor 3 (mostly efficient but could be tightened); not 4 because the duplication is more than minor, and not 2 because there is no conceptual over-explanation of things Claude already knows. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Provides concrete executable guidance: exact file paths (`.planning/milestones/v{{version}}-ROADMAP.md`), exact commands (`git tag -a v{{version}} -m "[milestone summary]"`, commit message `chore: archive v{{version}} milestone`), and exact skill invocations (`/skill:gsd-phase --insert <N>`). Anchor 4 (mostly executable with minor gaps); not 5 because the archive-filling and stats-gathering detail is delegated to the external workflow file rather than specified inline. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Clear numbered 0-8 sequence with explicit checkpoints: audit pre-flight with branch handling (gaps → insert closure phases), confirmation gates at steps 1-3, and the archive-before-delete rule guards the destructive REQUIREMENTS.md deletion, so no cap applies. Anchor 4 rather than 5 because there is no verification that archive files were successfully written before deletion proceeds, and no check that the commit/tag succeeded before offering next steps. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | References are well-signaled and one level deep in a dedicated <execution_context> section with an explicit "Load these files NOW" instruction, and the process overview is appropriately split from the detailed workflow. Anchor 4 rather than 5 because the referenced paths are unresolvable engine placeholders with no bundle files present to verify, and the inline process (full step list plus the pre-flight template block) substantially overlaps the external workflow content. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |