Content
85%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
This is a highly actionable maintainer workflow with an explicit sequence, executable commands, invariants, a pre-merge checklist, and error-recovery guidance — near-perfect on actionability and workflow clarity. Its weaknesses are a monolithic structure with no progressive disclosure (all detail inline in one long file) and minor redundant repetition in the opening.
Suggestions
Split each stage's touch-list and invariants into one-level-deep reference files (e.g. references/shared-contract.md, references/server-service.md, references/ui-card.md) and keep SKILL.md as the order-of-operations overview with links.
Delete the duplicated "Do NOT install this on production Paperclip agents" line and the repeated audience statement — state the developer/maintainer scope once.
Move the verbatim checkbox-PR file inventory into a reference (or rely solely on the `git show --stat 4d5322c82` pointer) so the canonical example stays stable as the repo drifts.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is dense with non-obvious, repo-specific facts (file paths, litigated invariants, exact idempotency key shape) and assumes competence, but there is redundant padding: "Do NOT install this on production Paperclip agents" appears verbatim at both the top and line 19, and the audience is restated three times in the opening. This is 'efficient with minor instances that could be trimmed' (level 4) rather than the every-token-earns-its-place level 5. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is fully executable: exact files to touch per layer (e.g. "server/src/services/issue-thread-interactions.ts — mapInteractionRow (the switch (row.kind)...)"), copy-paste commands ("git show --stat 4d5322c82", the complete NODE_ENV=test vitest invocation listing every test file), concrete schemas ("<kind>:<issueId>:<decisionKey>:<revisionId>"), and a worked canonical PR to model after. Matches the copy-paste-ready level-5 anchor. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The order of operations is explicitly sequenced with rationale ("Do the shared contract first. It is the smallest correct change you can land"), stages 1→2→3→3a→4→5 each carry per-layer invariants, and there are real validation checkpoints with a feedback loop: a "Tests to run before requesting review" command block, a pre-merge checklist, and error recovery ("If UI vitest fails with `act is not a function`... Re-run with NODE_ENV=test"). Matches the explicit-validation-with-recovery anchor at level 5. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | There are no bundle files at all (no references/, scripts/, or assets/), so the ~290-line SKILL.md inlines everything: per-layer file inventories, server/UI invariants, and channel guidance that would naturally live in one-level-deep reference files. The few external pointers (the connector playbook link, the PAP-10415 plan, the checkbox PR) are clearly signaled, but the bulk of detailed content that should be separate is inline, matching the level-3 anchor rather than level 4's 'most content appropriately placed'. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |