Argument check first: scan a draft in three passes for argument problems (straw men, false binaries, AI determinism, stakes inflation), then clarity and evidence gaps, then structural mechanics, logging each finding with location, verbatim line, diagnosis, and suggested fix. Flags, never scores. Use when the user asks to review, fact-check, tighten, or edit a draft before publishing — 'review my writing', 'edit my essay', 'argument check'. Runs as the last review lens on a draft, after the allergist and taste-lens.
96%
Does it follow best practices?
Run evals on this skill
Adds up to 20 points to the overall score
Passed
No findings from the security scan
The substantive editorial layer. It runs third, after the allergist and
taste-lens, and produces a findings report. It flags and never rewrites the
whole draft. The drafter fixes each finding under the your-words rule.
The allergist owns its allergy list (reversals, redirects, fortune-cookie closes, pseudo-Q&A, "Maybe" anaphora, the lexicon, unsourced numbers). The taste lens owns hedges, filler, and word-level style. A survivor from either means that lens missed it. Send the draft back instead of duplicating the flag.
TK, [link], [GAP: …], half-filled
templates.Make three full passes, one per category. For each finding, record the check name, location, the offending line verbatim, a one-sentence diagnosis, and a suggested fix.
A recurring failure with no home in this lens or the allergy list goes under
Watch-items at the bottom. Hand watch-items to the lessons skill. Never
edit this file or the allergy list from here.
Lead with the findings and skip the preamble.
Guardrails: clean. Watch-items: none.
Guardrails: 2 flags.
Clarity/evidence
- Missing so-what (¶3): "We moved the queue to its own node pool." The reader can't tell why this was the hard call. Fix: one sentence on what staying put was costing.
Argument
- False universality (¶7): "every platform team ends up here." Scope it to the teams you watched.
Watch-items: none
With 10 or more findings, skip the full list. Summarize the counts and top three patterns, and recommend a structural revision before any line edits.
shortrib-labs/content-loop
1e17068
If you maintain this skill, you can claim it as your own. Once claimed, you can manage eval scenarios, bundle related skills, attach documentation or rules, and ensure cross-agent compatibility.