Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-sequenced, highly concrete instruction set with clear phase gating and quantified rules, though it carries duplicated summary blocks and citation padding that dilute token efficiency. Its most serious defect is that all seven reference/*.md files and all _common/*.md files it instructs the agent to read are absent from the bundle, leaving the progressive-disclosure structure nominally good but functionally broken.
Suggestions
Ship the referenced files: add the missing references/ bundle (knowledge-synthesis.md, pattern-taxonomy.md, propagation-protocol.md, decay-detection.md, official-pattern-taxonomy.md, autorun-schema.md) or inline the critical tables/formats (LORE_INSIGHT format, authoritative TTL table) that the body currently delegates to them.
Remove the ~30-line HTML CAPABILITIES_SUMMARY comment and the Output Routing table that duplicates the Recipes/Trigger Guidance sections to reclaim token budget.
Specify how similarity percentages are computed (e.g. an embedding/keyword heuristic or checklist) so the '>= 80% cluster / 50-79% variant' rules are executable rather than abstract.
Trim research-justification citations (Zalando, Google SRE, MIT Sloan, Ebbinghaus) to one-line pointers or move them into a reference file — they cost context without changing behavior.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The operational rules are dense and mostly non-redundant (e.g. "Similarity >= 80% → cluster", "STALE > 180 days"), but there is notable padding: the ~30-line HTML CAPABILITIES_SUMMARY comment duplicates the Trigger Guidance and Collaboration sections, the Output Routing table largely repeats the Recipes table, and research justifications ("Zalando's 2-year postmortem analysis", "MIT Sloan: old knowledge prohibits absorption", "Ebbinghaus curve") add tokens without operational value. This fits anchor 3 — mostly efficient but includes unnecessary material that could be tightened — rather than 2, since no basic concepts Claude already knows are explained. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Highly concrete for an instruction-only skill: exact thresholds ("1 = Anecdote, 2 = Emerging, 3-5 = Pattern..."), TTL multipliers ("SECURITY 0.5× → stale after 90 days"), ID format ("[DOMAIN]-[TYPE]-[NNN]"), and journal format ("## YYYY-MM-DD - [Discovery/Insight]"). Not 5 because key executable mechanics are missing or dangling: no method for computing the "Similarity >= 80%" score, and the LORE_INSIGHT/LORE_ALERT formats are delegated to reference files that are not present in the bundle. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The "HARVEST → SYNTHESIZE → CATALOG → PROPAGATE → AUDIT" pipeline is clearly sequenced with a per-phase table of required actions, key rules, and read references, and checkpoints are embedded ("Check for contradictions before registration or promotion", "Promotion requires a new context, no active contradiction, and last evidence within 90 days", the AUDIT phase itself). Not 5 because validation gates are stated as rules rather than explicit gate/feedback-loop steps, and the decay phase's "decide on archival" lacks a decision sequence; comfortably above anchor 3's 'checkpoints missing or implicit'. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The in-body structure is good — clear sections plus a Reference Map table ("reference/decay-detection.md | You are evaluating freshness...") with one-level-deep, clearly signaled references — but none of the referenced files exist in the bundle: there is no references/ directory, and every cited path (reference/knowledge-synthesis.md, reference/pattern-taxonomy.md, reference/propagation-protocol.md, reference/decay-detection.md, reference/official-pattern-taxonomy.md, reference/autorun-schema.md, and all _common/*.md files) is absent. The disclosure chain is broken in practice, so the bulk of operational detail the body defers to is unreachable; this sits between anchors 3 and 4, and the missing files are more than a minor organization gap. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |