Content
78%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A well-architected routing skill: dense, symbol-precise guidance with no filler, a sequenced workflow with verification, a review checklist, and a correctly structured one-level reference bundle. The main improvements are precision — the "availability matrix below" pointer misdirects since the matrix lives in a reference file — and closing the loop between the workflow's verification step and the Common Mistakes remedies.
Suggestions
Fix the dangling pointer "The availability matrix below owns version details" — no matrix appears in the body; point precisely to the Availability notes in references/tabletopkit-patterns.md so readers can actually locate version requirements.
Close the feedback loop in Workflow step 5: state what to do when verification fails (e.g., "on rollback or snapshot mismatch, reconcile via TabletopGame.Observer and re-run the checklist") instead of leaving recovery implicit in Common Mistakes.
Inline one small copy-paste snippet for the most common setup path (seat claiming plus setup.register(action:)) so the body's guidance is executable without opening a reference, and drop the Contents TOC, which duplicates the section headers and Route by Task at this length.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~80-line body assumes Claude's competence — no explanation of what visionOS, RealityKit, or SharePlay are — and every section carries information. Minor trimmable content exists: the Contents TOC is redundant with headers and Route by Task for this length, and Core Decisions items ("Treat SharePlay transport, reconnection, and late joining as lifecycle states") partially restate Workflow step 5 and checklist items. Efficient with minor trim opportunities fits anchor 4; not 5 because a few tokens do not earn their place. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Highly concrete symbol-level guidance throughout: "claimAnySeat() or claimSeat(_:)", "setup.register(action:)", "actionWasRolledBack(_:snapshot:)", "outcome.tossableRepresentation.face(for: outcome.restingOrientation)", ".tabletopGame(_:parent:automaticUpdate:)" on RealityView, plus hard environmental facts ("Group Activities do not work in Simulator", "multiplayer requires 2+ Apple Vision Pro units on FaceTime"). Not 5: no executable code snippet lives in the body, and "The availability matrix below owns version details" points to a matrix that is not below — it resides in references/tabletopkit-patterns.md's Availability notes — leaving one routing instruction imprecise. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The five-step workflow is clearly sequenced with an opening checkpoint ("Confirm visionOS availability, TabletopKit capability, and whether the experience needs local, shared, or SharePlay-backed play") and an explicit verification step ("Verify reset, reconnect, late-join, undo, and multi-participant behavior"), reinforced by a 12-item review checklist. Falls between anchors 4 and 5: error-recovery knowledge exists (Common Mistakes covers rollback, discarded actions, invalid parentID) but is not looped back into the workflow as "if X fails, do Y" steps, so the anchor-5 feedback-loop criterion is only implicitly met. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | A genuine entrypoint: the body stays an overview while 1,277 lines of detail are split across three real, one-level-deep reference files, each signaled twice with descriptions (Route by Task and References), and cross-links between reference files are sibling-level, not nested. Verified against the actual bundle — all three referenced paths (references/core-implementation.md, references/tabletopkit-patterns.md, references/tabletop-networking-and-state.md) exist and carry the promised content. Clear overview, well-signaled one-level references, easy navigation matches anchor 5; the misleading "below" pointer to the availability matrix is too small to drop it to anchor 4's "references mostly clear". | 5 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |