Content
67%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is well-structured with a clear sequenced workflow and excellent one-level-deep reference pointers that all resolve to real files and sections. Its main weakness is token efficiency: an inline strategy catalog, speculative integration sections, redundant notes, and a time-sensitive rate all add tokens without teaching Claude anything new.
Suggestions
Move the 18-strategy catalog definitions to a reference file (keeping only the strategy names as a supported-scope list) — Claude already knows what a covered call or iron condor is.
Delegate Step 5's P/L implementation (calculate_pnl and the price-range snippet) to references/strategy_analysis_examples.md to match the delegation pattern used for Steps 3, 4, and 6-9.
Trim the 'Integration with Other Skills', 'Important Notes', and 'Troubleshooting' sections of redundant content, and replace the hard-coded '~5.3% as of 2025' T-bill rate with guidance to look up the current rate.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body inlines an 18-strategy catalog that re-explains concepts Claude already knows ('Covered Call - Own stock, sell call (generate income, cap upside)'), plus padding in 'Integration with Other Skills' and 'Important Notes' (repeating dependencies, 'All analysis in English') and the time-sensitive '~5.3% as of 2025' T-bill rate. The skeleton is efficient, but several sections could be trimmed or delegated, matching 'mostly efficient but includes some unnecessary explanation'. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | The quick-start snippet is executable against the real scripts/black_scholes.py, and the HV calculation and price-range code are concrete; input requirements are enumerated per step. The Step 5 calculate_pnl function references an undefined strategy.legs structure (leg.premium_paid, leg.position, num_contracts), leaving minor gaps between it and fully copy-paste-ready guidance. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clear 9-step analysis workflow with inputs specified up front and a Troubleshooting section covering failure modes (negative option price, wrong Greeks, missing IV). The error-recovery guidance is separated from the main flow rather than embedded as explicit validation checkpoints, so it stops short of the anchor requiring feedback loops within the sequence. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Per-step pointers ('Read references/black_scholes_methodology.md (section "Step 4 detail: Calculate Greeks") when calculating Greeks') are well-signaled, one level deep, and every referenced file and section was verified to exist. Minor gap: Step 5's full P/L implementation is inlined in SKILL.md while sibling steps (3, 4, 6-9) delegate to references, an inconsistency in the otherwise good split. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |