Content
81%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A dense, highly operational instruction body: clear step sequence with validation checkpoints and error-recovery guidance, concrete platform-specific commands, and appropriately delegated detail. The two notable weaknesses are the missing agents/inspector-*.md files that deep-audit routing depends on, and several overloaded run-on policy paragraphs that would be more reliable as lists or tables.
Suggestions
Ship the three referenced `agents/inspector-context.md`, `agents/inspector-control.md`, and `agents/inspector-maintainability.md` files in the bundle, or replace the deep-inspector routing with inline local-analysis instructions, since Step 2 currently points at files that do not exist.
Split the longest policy paragraphs (Budget posture escalation triggers, "Codex/Claude/Pi instruction drift", "Deny-list floor" with its three inline calibrations) into bullet lists or tables so each rule is independently readable and none gets lost in a run-on sentence.
Give one concrete resolved example of `<skill-base-dir>` (or state how it is determined at load time) so the copy-paste launcher snippets need no guesswork before first use.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | No tokens are spent on concepts Claude already knows; nearly every line is operational policy ("Treat `(unavailable)` as insufficient data, not a finding"). Falls short of 5 because several dense multi-clause passages (the Budget posture escalation list, the "Codex/Claude/Pi instruction drift" paragraph, the "Deny-list floor" calibrations) run on and could be tightened into lists; well above 3 since there is no unnecessary explanation. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Copy-paste-ready launchers for Windows and Bash with candidate resolution and failure messages, exact re-run commands ("BASH_ENV= ENV= /bin/bash -p "$HEALTH_SCRIPT" auto deep"), and a fully concrete finding example with an exact remediation command ("git rm --cached .claude/settings.local.json ..."). Not 5: Step 2 says "Read `agents/inspector-context.md`" (and inspector-control/maintainability) but those files are absent from the bundle, and `<skill-base-dir>` placeholders require substitution. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A clearly sequenced Steps 0→1→1b→1c→2→Output flow with explicit escalation triggers, completion checkpoints ("Before reporting a deep audit as complete, wait for every launched inspector and reconcile its assigned scope"), data-validation handling ("(unavailable)" sections, refuted findings dropped), an error-recovery fallback ("If a subagent fails, analyze that layer locally"), and a Gotchas table of failure modes. This matches the anchor for a clear sequence with explicit validation and error-recovery feedback loops. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The references that exist are one level deep, well-signaled, and scope-gated ("load `references/long-running-agents.md` and audit the four hard stop signals it lists"; "See [references/durable-context.md] ... for ... the redaction gate"), and all three references/ files plus the named scripts exist. However, the three `agents/inspector-*.md` files referenced in Step 2 are missing from the bundle, a real navigation gap — better than anchor 3 (references are clearly signaled, not buried) but short of anchor 5 (referenced paths must resolve). | 4 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |