Content
62%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A rigorously sequenced, highly actionable orchestration skill whose verification and feedback machinery is exemplary. Its weaknesses are token efficiency — the same assurance/gating logic is explained two to three times across 759 lines — and progressive disclosure, with heavy inline policy content and externalized references that are not part of the bundle.
Suggestions
State the assurance-level derivation once (Phase 0) and have Phase 6.0 reference it ('re-derive per Phase 0; on disagreement overwrite and warn') instead of restating the full 5-step rule, cutting ~60 lines of duplication.
Move the Phase 6.0 verifier-resolution bash, the pre-flight checklist, and the audit emission rules into a shared-references file (or a bundled references/audit-gates.md) and link to it, leaving SKILL.md a lean phase-by-phase overview.
Trim the 'Empirical motivation' and 'Why this is the most diagnostic' narrative paragraphs to one-line rationale notes; the failure modes they describe can be carried by the audit sub-skills themselves.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The 759-line body restates the assurance-level derivation in full in both Phase 0 and Phase 6.0, and describes the audit gates in Phases 4.5/4.7/5.5/5.8 and again in the Phase 6.0 pre-flight checklist, 'Invoking the four audits', and the remediation list, plus multi-paragraph 'Empirical motivation' narratives. It is operationally dense rather than padded with basics Claude already knows, so it sits above anchor 1 but clearly matches 'several unnecessary explanations or padded sections'. | 2 / 5 |
Actionability | Phases give exact invocations ('/paper-plan "$ARGUMENTS"', '/paper-compile "paper/"'), copy-paste bash (numeric-claim rg detector, verifier resolution chain), and concrete checkpoint templates. Falls short of 5 because some snippets leave placeholders unresolved locally ($GATE_HELPER, $ANTI_AR_COMMIT, <ARIS_REPO>) or use pseudo-if blocks, deferring full contracts to external files. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The pipeline is an explicitly sequenced Phase 0–6 chain with per-phase skip conditions, checkpoints, an itemized submission pre-flight checklist, verifier exit codes as the source of truth, and feedback loops everywhere (fix-then-rerun verifier, max-3-round contract negotiation with fallback, 3 compile attempts, STALE/MISSING remediation paths). This matches the anchor for clear sequencing with explicit validation and error-recovery loops. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | References like '../shared-references/integration-contract.md' and 'review-scope-limits.md' are clearly signaled but live outside the skill directory and no bundle files (references/, scripts/, assets/) exist in this skill, while large gate/contract logic that belongs in those shared files is inlined (and duplicated) in the body. Structure exists but content that should be separate is inline, matching anchor 3 rather than 4. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |