Content
77%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a tightly sequenced, highly actionable phase workflow with pervasive validation checkpoints (per-rung exit-code gates, regression re-runs, fix budgets, re-sweep rounds) and copy-paste templates and prompts. It loses points on redundancy — the same-family provisional rule is repeated four times and the Phase 4 reviewer message inlines ~50 lines whose scope limits duplicate a referenced shared doc — and on inlining that prompt rather than splitting it into a bundle reference file.
Suggestions
State the same-family provisional rule once (e.g., in the 'Review assurance' blockquote near the top) and reference it from Phase 4, the assurance table, and the anti-patterns list instead of repeating it four separate times.
Move the ~50-line Phase 4 spawn_agent reviewer message into a bundle file (e.g., references/sweep-reviewer-prompt.md); its SCOPE LIMITS section already duplicates shared-references/review-scope-limits.md, so the inline copy can collapse to a pointer.
Trim the two opening blockquotes (Selectable Reviewers, Review assurance) to one-line pointers into ../shared-references/reviewer-backends.md and reviewer-independence.md so SKILL.md reads as an overview rather than embedding routing policy inline.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly operational (templates, commands, tables) with no basic-concept padding, but it could be tightened: the same-family-provisional rule is stated four separate times (opening 'Review assurance' blockquote, Phase 4 table row, 'Review limitation' paragraph, and an anti-pattern bullet), and the ~50-line Phase 4 reviewer message inlines scope limits that the referenced shared-references/review-scope-limits.md already covers. This matches anchor 3 ('mostly efficient… could be tightened') rather than anchor 2, since there is no conceptual explanation of things Claude already knows. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is fully executable throughout: one-command acceptance checks ('python scripts/run.py --smoke && test -f out/smoke.json', 'pytest tests/test_loader.py'), 'git rev-parse HEAD' for the base commit, copy-paste markdown templates for ASSUMPTIONS.md and BUILD_NOTE.md, a ready-to-use spawn_agent reviewer message, and an exact JSON return contract ('{"undeclared": [...], "stale_rows": [...], "semantic_undeclared": N, "verdict": "clean"|"gaps"}') — matching anchor 5's copy-paste-ready coverage of common cases. | 5 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | Phases 0–5 are strictly sequenced with explicit validation at every step: each rung's check requires exit 0, 'Every earlier rung's check → all exit 0' enforces regression gates, fix budgets create retry loops, exhaustion fills *Blockers* and stops the ladder, and the sweep re-runs up to a round budget — clear sequence, explicit validation, and feedback loops per anchor 5. The destructive/batch cap does not apply because validation checkpoints are pervasive rather than missing. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | References are clearly signaled (inline links plus an annotated See Also listing eight shared references), but the skill bundle itself contains no files (no references/, scripts/, or assets/), every referenced document lives outside the bundle in ../shared-references/ where its existence cannot be verified from the skill, and the ~50-line Phase 4 reviewer prompt is inlined content that belongs in a separate reference file — its SCOPE LIMITS section even duplicates an existing shared reference. This matches anchor 3 ('content that should be separate is inline') rather than anchor 4, whose 'minor organization gaps' understates that misplacement. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |