Content
81%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is a well-structured orchestration skill: a clearly sequenced five-phase pipeline with genuine validation gates and feedback loops, concrete output paths, and copy-paste templates. Weakest points are mild redundancy across the outputs/template/summary sections and heavy inline reviewer-routing policy whose referenced shared files are absent from the bundle.
Suggestions
Reduce repetition of the output file list: the Default Outputs, Phase 4 template, and Phase 5 summary block each restate the same refine-logs paths — state them once and reference that list from the template and summary.
Trim the reviewer-routing blockquote to a two-line pointer to ../shared-references/reviewer-backends.md and move the routing-resolution policy detail into that reference file.
Add a short worked example of a completed Phase 2 gate check (thesis, dominant contribution, rejected complexity, residual reviewer concerns) so the gate is executable rather than only a question list.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is mostly efficient — tight bullet lists per phase, a core rule stated in two sentences, and templates instead of prose. Minor redundancy keeps it below 5: the output file names are repeated across Default Outputs, the Phase 4 template, and the Phase 5 summary block, and the dense reviewer-routing blockquote inlines policy detail that belongs in its referenced shared file. It is well above the 'noticeably verbose' level of 2. | 4 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is concrete and executable for an orchestration skill: exact output paths, explicit stage exit criteria ('Exit this stage only when these are explicit: ...'), decisive triage rules ('If in doubt, prefer re-running research-refine'), and a copy-paste-ready PIPELINE_SUMMARY.md template. It falls short of 5 only because stage execution itself is delegated to sibling skills and the Phase 2 gate check has questions but no worked example — minor gaps, not the vague abstraction of level 2. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The Phase 0-5 sequence is clearly ordered with explicit validation checkpoints and feedback loops: Phase 0 triages whether the existing FINAL_PROPOSAL.md is missing/stale/mismatched with reuse-vs-rerun rules, Phase 1 defines explicit exit criteria, and Phase 2 is a planning gate that loops back ('If these answers are not crisp, tighten the final proposal first'). This matches the anchor-5 pattern of clear sequence, explicit validation steps, and error-recovery loops. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Structure is good: stage-specific detail is deferred to sibling skills 'only when needed' (one level deep, clearly signaled), and shared protocols are consolidated in an Output Protocols section. It falls short of 5 because the referenced bundle files (../research-refine/SKILL.md, ../experiment-plan/SKILL.md, ../shared-references/*.md) are not present in the provided bundle so the links cannot be verified, and the reviewer-routing policy block is inlined rather than kept in its referenced file — but the body itself is well-sectioned, well above the buried-reference problems of level 3. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 17 / 20 Passed |