Content
92%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The body is an exceptionally lean orchestrator for a complex multi-stage pipeline: a moment-based loading table with one-level-deep references (all verified to exist), checker-driven decision tables with explicit validation and repair feedback loops, and stage markers that checkpoint progress and enable resume. The main gap is that only the asset-inspection command is fully inline, while the plan/digest/mark-stage subcommands and the GBK→UTF-8 conversion step lack copy-paste-ready forms in the body itself.
Suggestions
Inline a one-line copy-paste skeleton for the core manage_analysis_run.py subcommands (e.g. plan --intent continue, digest, mark-stage) with their required arguments, so the common continue/repair paths are executable without opening pipeline-ops.md.
Add the concrete encoding-conversion command (e.g. iconv -f GBK -t UTF-8) next to the 原文.txt setup note, since the body currently only states that non-UTF-8 (常见为 GBK) input must be converted before subagents read it.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~90-line body orchestrates a 7-stage pipeline with zero filler: no general concepts are explained, and every line carries operational content (e.g. "已有摘要一律不覆盖:要重拆某章就删掉它的 `章节/第N章_摘要.md` 和覆盖它的 `_analysis_cache/批次-*.md`"). It matches the score-5 anchor — lean, assumes competence, every token earns its place — with nothing to trim down to score 4's 'minor instances of over-explanation'. | 5 / 5 |
Actionability | Phase 1 provides a fully executable checker command ("{PYTHON}" .../scripts/inspect_existing_assets.py --root "拆文库/{书名}" --compact) plus the Python-resolution and directory conventions, and subcommands are named with intent flags (plan --intent continue, digest, mark-stage). However, full invocations for those stage commands are deferred to reference files rather than being copy-paste ready in the body, matching score 4 ('mostly executable; concrete commands with minor gaps') rather than 5. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The multi-stage sequence is explicit (Stage 0→1→stop-and-ask→2–6, gated by Phase 1/2 checker output) with validation checkpoints throughout: the read-only checker, index validation rules ("落表前校验章号连续、无重复和边界有效"), "路径错误必须停止", per-stage disk markers (标 stageN), and final-checks.md. Feedback loops are present for error recovery (repair_stages/enhance_existing paths, index-rebuild fallback with author-facing options, invalid_topic_decision_contract → rerun story-long-scan Phase 5), and batch extraction is bounded ("Stage 2 默认每轮 3 批有限并行") with cache-based resume — matching the score-5 anchor. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The 按时刻读 table routes each working moment to exactly the reference file needed, all 12 referenced files exist in references/, and the structure is hub-and-spoke: every reference is one level deep, directly linked from SKILL.md (sibling cross-links are conveniences, not hidden chains), with scripts bundled and invoked by path. This matches the score-5 anchor — clear overview, well-signaled one-level-deep references, easy navigation. | 5 / 5 |
Total | 19 / 20 Passed |