Content
53%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
The security-report half of the body is well-built: specific templates, a clear flavor-selection table, concrete output rules, and a final self-check. However, the ACTION REQUIRED block references a nonexistent '工作流' section and missing parent-level files, instructions are repeated across sections, and the generic documentation-writing half restates knowledge Claude already has.
Suggestions
Define an actual ordered 工作流 section (gather evidence → select template → pick flavor → draft → self-check) or remove the '进入工作流第一步' directive, since the body currently tells the reader to enter a workflow that does not exist.
Remove or fix broken parent-relative references (../tool-index.md, ../ops/evidence-finding-path.md, ../scripts/case-init.ps1) and reconcile the contradiction between 'ACTION REQUIRED' step 3 (call bootstrap when tools are missing) and '按需自举' stating no bootstrap is needed.
Deduplicate the vendor-report-rules/flavor guidance (stated in 模板选择, 厂商报告结构, 质量要求, and 路由上下文) into a single section, and trim the generic Core Principles/Formatting Standards/Anti-Patterns content that restates standard technical-writing knowledge.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The security-report workflow is dense and specific, but there is real tightening to do: 'MUST 读取 references/vendor-report-rules.md' and the flavor rules are restated three times (模板选择, 质量要求, 路由上下文), the template file list is duplicated in 路由上下文, and ~50 lines of Core Principles/Formatting Standards/Anti-Patterns teach writing conventions Claude already knows. Matches 'mostly efficient but includes some unnecessary explanation'; not 2 because the security half is accurate, dense table-driven content rather than padded prose. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Concrete elements exist (filename format 'YYYY-MM-DD_[类型]-[目标简称]-report.md', template-selection and flavor tables, output/language rules), but the ACTION REQUIRED block directs reading '../tool-index.md' which does not exist, step 4 says '进入"工作流"第一步' while no 工作流 section exists in the body, and '../ops/evidence-finding-path.md' and '../scripts/case-init.ps1' are also missing. Key execution details are dangling, matching 'some concrete guidance but incomplete'; not 4 because broken and dangling references are more than minor gaps. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | A rough sequence is distributed across sections (触发时机 → 模板选择 → 输出规范 → 任务完成自检 as a final validation checklist), but the steps are never assembled into one ordered workflow, intermediate checkpoints are implicit, and the headline 'ACTION REQUIRED' step points to a nonexistent '工作流' section. Matches 'steps listed but validation gaps; sequence present but checkpoints missing or implicit'; not 4 because the core execution path the reader is told to enter does not exist. | 3 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | The three real bundle files (references/security-report-templates.md, templates.md, vendor-report-rules.md) are each referenced with clear purpose via the template-selection table and explicit MUST-read directives, one level deep — good structure. Not 5 because navigation is polluted by broken parent-relative references (../tool-index.md, ../ops/evidence-finding-path.md, ../scripts/case-init.ps1) and flavor/quality detail is inlined in the body instead of living in the references. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 13 / 20 Passed |