Content
63%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A rich, evidence-driven feedback-handling procedure with concrete decision gates, explicit validation loops, and ready-to-use templates. Its main costs are a monolithic single-file structure that inlines reviewer-side and lifecycle content with a dangling script reference, and repeated restatement of the same closure rules across sections that inflates the token budget.
Suggestions
Split reviewer-side material out of the body — the F253 Delta Annotation table, TAKEOVER 降级, and 沙盒生命周期 sections — into a reference file (or back into request-review/shared-rules), keeping SKILL.md as the author-side feedback loop.
Consolidate the thrice-repeated closure/合入门禁 rules into one authoritative section and cross-reference it, cutting redundancy between 必须做到, 修复后确认, and the cloud-path guidance.
Ship the referenced script (or fix the path) so 'node scripts/check-fallback-layers.mjs' is executable as written, and add a one-line note on where it lives.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The ~290-line body is dense with domain-specific policy rather than concepts Claude already knows, so it is far from anchor 2's padded explanations. But the same closure rules are stated three or more times ('不得自称通过未满足的合入门禁' recurs in 必须做到, the engagement section, and the cloud section), and sections like the Reviewer Delta Annotation (F253) table and 沙盒生命周期 address the reviewer's workflow, not the feedback receiver this skill targets — it 'could be tightened' to anchor 3 rather than the trimmable-minor-excess of anchor 4. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is largely executable for an instruction-only skill: a stepwise READ→CLASSIFY→…→CLOSE flow, three decision gates with explicit branches ('冲突 → pushback,附 AC 原文'), a fill-in confirmation-letter template, concrete bash commands ('pnpm worktree:finish /tmp/cat-cafe-review/{review-target-id}/{reviewer-handle} --source-ref {review-subject-ref}'), and a browser-verification checklist. It is not anchor 5 because several directives defer to external contracts not in the bundle (request-review's carrier/verdict state machine, shared-rules §16e/§18) and the audit step's 'grep 本 PR diff 里所有同类位置' leaves the search itself to the model. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The optional 处理顺序 block gives a clear 7-step sequence with named checkpoints, and validation is explicit throughout: RED must be saved before GREEN ('有则运行并保存 RED'), fixed paths are re-verified, the Feature Gate mandates rollback ('功能死了 → 回滚'), and the UX section has a literal 验证清单. It misses anchor 5 because the definitive sequence is explicitly labeled '可选参考' amid many parallel sections, and the mixed author/reviewer roles (TAKEOVER, sandbox cleanup) make the primary path harder to follow without re-reading. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Section headers exist and external references are clearly signaled ('详见 ../.cat-cafe-shared-refs/pr-signals.md'), but there is no bundle at all — no references/, scripts/, or assets/ — while the body inlines ~290 lines that clearly belong in separate files (delta-annotation spec for reviewers, sandbox lifecycle mechanics, confirmation-letter formats), matching 'content that should be separate is inline'. It also cites 'node scripts/check-fallback-layers.mjs', a script that does not exist in this bundle, which is below anchor 4's 'references mostly clear' reliability. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 14 / 20 Passed |