The body is largely efficient with exact paths and templates, but the "Important reminders" section restates constraints already given in Steps 3 and 5 (every dimension id must appear, scores within range, schema conformance), so it could be tightened. Not a 1 because there is no concept-explaining fluff; not a 3 because of the duplicated reminder content.

Provides concrete, executable guidance — exact file paths, the precise JSON output shape with required fields, and explicit formulas like "sum(dimension.score * dimension.weight)". Not a 2 because the templates are complete and copy-paste ready rather than pseudocode.

Five clearly sequenced steps with explicit validation checkpoints (schema conformance, score-range checks) and a feedback loop for the judge-failure branch ("set success: false and populate errorMessage"). Not a 2 because checkpoints are explicit rather than implicit.

Single self-contained, well-sectioned document with one-level-deep references (./rubrics/, ./config.json, ./references/, schemas/results.schema.json) that were verified to exist. Not a 2 because there is no inline wall of text or nested 2+ level reference chain.

Lists multiple concrete actions — "dynamically discovers the rubric files", "scores the skill against each", "producing one result per rubric" — matching the anchor for multiple specific concrete actions. It is not a 2 because the actions are comprehensive for the task rather than partial.

Explicitly answers what ("dynamically discovers the rubric files and scores the skill against each, producing one result per rubric") and when via an explicit "Use when running a skill review workflow or testing skill quality against configurable rubrics" clause. Not a 2 because the trigger is explicit rather than implied.

Includes natural phrases a user would say — "skill review workflow", "testing skill quality", "against configurable rubrics" — giving good coverage. Not a 2 because common natural variations are present rather than only jargon.

Targets a clear niche (skill-quality evaluation via rubric files) with distinct triggers unlikely to fire for unrelated skills. Not a 2 because it does not merely name a broad domain like "Works with document files".