Session debrief template + tour-coverage tracker - captures the SBTM PROOF format (Past, Results, Obstacles, Outlook, Feelings) plus three-bucket time accounting (test design / setup / bug investigation), the tours applied + areas covered + areas skipped, and the per-session quality-of-attention signal. Output is the artifact a charter delivers into; the team aggregates debriefs across sessions to track what's been explored vs what's still uncharted. Use after every exploratory session - without the debrief, the session's findings disappear.
75
94%
Does it follow best practices?
Run evals on this skill
Adds up to 20 points to the overall score
View guide
Passed
No findings from the security scan
Deep reference for manual-test-debrief SKILL.md. The skill body carries
a blank PROOF template; this file holds the fully-filled example plus the
two aggregation artifacts.
# Session debrief - `<session-id>`
**Charter:** [link to charter]
**Tester:** _______________
**Date:** _______________
**Time-box:** 90 min **Actual:** ___ min
**Build / Environment:** _______________
## Past - what was tested
**Tours applied:**
- [x] Money tour (per `exploratory-tours-reference`)
- [x] Bad-data tour
- [ ] Configuration tour (skipped - out of time)
**Areas covered:**
- Promo code input field - full coverage including SQL/XSS payloads
- Promo discount math - 10% / 50% / 100% / fractional cent edge cases
- Promo + tax interaction - covered for US tax states only
**Paths walked (notable ones):**
- Apply WELCOME10 to $24.99 cart -> $22.49 (pass)
- Apply two stackable promos -> second silently overrides first (BUG-987)
- Apply expired promo -> graceful error message (pass)
## Results - what was learned
**Confirmed working:**
- Single-promo apply
- Promo code expiration enforcement
- Free-shipping promo
**Bugs found:** (with bug IDs)
- BUG-987: Stacking two promos doesn't combine - second silently overrides first.
- BUG-988: SQL injection in promo input field returns 500 instead of 400.
- BUG-989: $0.01 cart with 50% off rounds to $0.00 instead of $0.01.
**Surprises:**
- Discount is applied to subtotal BEFORE tax, but the original SOW
said after-tax. Need to clarify with PM.
- "WELCOME10" code is case-sensitive; "welcome10" silently rejected
with no helpful message.
**Confirmed-fixed (vs prior session):**
- Previous BUG-832 (promo input losing focus) is fixed. (pass)
## Outlook - what's left
**Areas not covered (out of time / scope):**
- EU tax cases (covered separately by next session's charter).
- Multi-currency promo behavior.
- Promo + subscription billing.
**Recommended next charter:**
- "Explore the EU tax + promo interaction" (90 min).
- "Explore promo + subscription billing edge cases" (60 min).
**Open questions for PM / dev team:**
- Confirm: discount before vs after tax (cited as "before" in
current implementation; SOW says "after").
- Confirm: should case-insensitive promo codes be supported?
## Obstacles
**Setup pain:**
- Stripe test card kept timing out at checkout - added 5 min to
the session.
- Required test promo codes weren't pre-seeded; had to create them
manually.
**Environment instability:**
- Staging was down for ~10 min mid-session; lost momentum.
**Recommendations for next session:**
- Pre-seed promo codes via a fixture per `synthetic-data-tool-selector`.
- Verify staging is up before session start.
## Feelings
**Quality of attention this session:** Strong (focused throughout;
caught the BUG-987 cluster early which sustained interest).
**Confidence in the feature:** Mixed. The single-promo path is
solid; the multi-promo path has architectural issues that aren't
just bugs (SOW ambiguity on discount-before-tax suggests the
business hasn't fully decided).
**Unease about untested areas:** Moderate. Multi-currency promos
weren't touched; gut says there are bugs there.
**Recommendation to release manager:** Block release until
BUG-987 (stacking) and BUG-988 (SQL injection) are fixed.
BUG-989 (rounding) is low impact; can ship with known-issue note.
## Time accounting (3-bucket)
| Bucket | Minutes |
|-------------------|--------:|
| Test design | 35 |
| Setup | 25 |
| Bug investigation | 30 |
| **Total actual** | 90 |Aggregating debriefs surfaces patterns individual reports can't:
## Quarterly debrief rollup - Q2 2026
**Sessions completed:** 47
**Bugs raised:** 138
**Average session: 90-min charter, 3-bucket: 38 / 28 / 24**
### Areas by coverage
| Area | Sessions | Bugs found | Last covered |
|----------------------------|---------:|-----------:|--------------|
| Checkout - promo flow | 8 | 34 | 2026-04-28 |
| Checkout - payment | 6 | 19 | 2026-05-02 |
| Account - subscription | 4 | 12 | 2026-05-05 |
| Account - profile | 3 | 8 | 2026-04-15 |
| Admin panel | 1 | 2 | 2026-03-20 | (stale)
| Reports | 0 | 0 | (never) | (uncovered)
### Action items from rollup
- Schedule sessions for Admin panel + Reports areas (under-covered).
- Subscription area surfaced 12 bugs - investigate root-cause
pattern.
- Average setup time (28 min) is high - invest in fixture tooling.The rollup shows what's been explored vs what's stale vs what's never been touched. Charter authoring uses this to pick where the next session focuses.
The Feelings section produces a per-session subjective signal. Track it over time:
| Session | Feelings (numeric: 1-5) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| ses-201 | 4 | Strong; BUG cluster found early. |
| ses-202 | 2 | Weak; tester sick / distracted. |
| ses-203 | 5 | Excellent; new tester, fresh eyes. |
When attention is consistently low across a tester / area, change something - different tester, different time-box, different tour, different scope.