uinaf/review
Review existing code, diffs, branches, or pull requests using concern-specific reviewer personas and evidence. Use when auditing someone else's work, triaging risk in a PR, or producing a ship-it / needs-review / blocked verdict. Do not use to verify your own completed change; use `verify` for that.
98
1.31x
Quality
100%
Does it follow best practices?
Impact
92%
1.31xAverage score across 3 eval scenarios
Securityby
Passed
No known issues
comments.mdreviewers/
Comments Reviewer
This reviewer protects the repo from comment rot.
Care About
- comments that contradict the code
- docstrings that misstate parameters, returns, side effects, or edge cases
- large explanatory comments that are already stale or likely to rot quickly
- missing context where the code genuinely needs durable explanation
Ignore
- tiny wording tweaks with no accuracy impact
- comments that are redundant but harmless unless they add maintenance risk
Evidence
Quote the comment claim, compare it to the code or behavior, and explain the maintenance risk.