Skill-Judge Canonical Integration

This file integrates the canonical skill-judge framework into skill-quality-auditor.

Source

• Upstream snapshot path: ../deadalus/.agents/skills/skill-judge/SKILL.md
• Upstream skill name: skill-judge
• Upstream purpose: evaluate skill design quality against official specifications and best practices.

Canonical Principles

1. Skills should maximize knowledge delta.
2. Skills should transfer expert thinking patterns, not tutorials.
3. Skills should include explicit anti-patterns with consequences.
4. Description quality controls activation quality.
5. Progressive disclosure should keep SKILL.md concise.

Canonical Dimensions

The canonical framework evaluates across 8 dimensions totaling 120 points.

Dimension	Max	Local implementation
Knowledge Delta	20	framework-skill-judge-dimensions.md
Mindset + Procedures	15	framework-skill-judge-dimensions.md
Anti-Pattern Quality	15	framework-skill-judge-dimensions.md
Specification Compliance	15	framework-scoring-rubric.md
Progressive Disclosure	15	framework-scoring-rubric.md
Freedom Calibration	15	framework-scoring-rubric.md
Pattern Recognition	10	framework-scoring-rubric.md
Practical Usability	15	framework-quality-standards.md

Sync Procedure

1. Compare this file and framework-skill-judge-dimensions.md against upstream skill-judge.
2. If upstream semantics change, update local dimensions and rubric references first.
3. Re-run audits using scripts/evaluate.sh and scripts/audit-skills.sh.
4. Record version notes in the audit report under .context/analysis/.

Notes

This file intentionally keeps only canonical integration metadata and mapping. Detailed evaluator guidance remains in the existing framework reference files.