Content
73%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
A rigorously engineered workflow document: gated phases, explicit validation and rework loops, concrete templates, commands, and numeric acceptance criteria, backed by a real, well-organized reference bundle with an on-demand reading index. Its weaknesses are verbosity — the same route/generation/CMYK policies are restated across five or more sections and could be consolidated — and deferral of the most executable details (render invocation syntax, prompt skeletons) to references, which leaves the body's core loop one step short of copy-paste ready.
Suggestions
State each route policy once (e.g., in the §2 route table) and cross-reference it by its 代号 from the principles, gates, §6 signals, and §8 checklist — the CMYK/Ghostscript procedure alone is currently given three times, and consolidating these restatements would cut roughly 30% of the body without losing any rule.
Inline a minimal render_file invocation example (the exact call shape used by the 画板探针 gate) and one image_generate prompt 骨架 so the core generate-then-render loop is executable without opening references/implementation-routing.md.
Move the font-selection table (§2 字体选型) into a reference file (e.g., references/typography.md) and keep only the routing rule and the 中文排版底线 list in the body, matching how the poster-examples index is already handled.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is entirely operational (no explanations of concepts Claude already knows) but restates the same rules many times: the "SVG 是输出格式不是路线 / 生成层必须存在" rule appears in the five principles, the §2 route table ("不存在 manual_svg、decorative_css、placeholder_as_final 路线"), the §3 tool table, the 素材层 gate, and the §6 signal list; the CMYK-via-Ghostscript rule is given three times (第零步, §3 table, §3 close), and the "不生成的理由都不是理由" list is repeated across §2 and §3. This sits between anchors 2 and 3 — the redundancy is deliberate gate enforcement rather than padded filler, so it lands at 3, but a ~30% cut restating each rule once and cross-referencing by 代号 (P1–P7) would fit anchor 4-5. | 3 / 5 |
Actionability | Guidance is mostly executable: copy-paste-ready YAML templates for the decision card, 最小系统合同, REFERENCE-CONTRACT, and KIT-MANIFEST; concrete commands and parameters ("node master/render.mjs", "render_file(scale=印刷 4 / 大幅面与数字 2, motion_mode=static, output_dir=proof/probe)", "96 px/in", "300 dpi / 150 dpi", "potrace / vtracer", npm font packages); and precise numeric criteria (标题 1/4–1/3 画板高, 信息层底部 1/5, 引用面积 ≥ 35%, 每 3 m 约 25 mm 字高). Minor gaps keep it below 5: the actual render_file/Playwright invocation syntax, an image_generate prompt 骨架 example, and the render.mjs/data.json structure are deferred to reference files rather than shown, and no inline HTML canvas snippet demonstrates the five-layer board. | 4 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The sequence is explicitly gated and ordered: 入口 gate (§0) → task reading and 档位 translation → 标杆索引 gate → direction/contract/candidates/fonts → 画板探针 gate before any asset → 素材层 gate before the 定调帧 → hero frame with a pixel-check order → series/master rollout → refactor signals → risk-based checks → completion checklist. Feedback loops are explicit throughout ("探针失败就停下修字体或环境", "生成失败…最多两轮再换 prompt 骨架", "P7 与 P1 不成立时重生成素材或回到最小系统合同"), and the six/seven named rework tests plus the §8 checklist match the anchor-5 pattern of validation steps with error-recovery loops. | 5 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | References are one level deep, all verified to exist, and well signaled with purpose and read-condition: "骨架与各档位裁剪见[交付骨架](references/deliverable-skeleton.md)", "按需读取[营销传播模式](references/patterns.md)", and the poster-examples INDEX.md table prescribing exactly which images to read per task. What keeps it at 4 rather than 5: the body itself is ~380 lines where some inlined material (the font-selection table, repeated route-policy restatements) clearly belongs in reference files, and several dependencies are cross-skill paths outside this bundle ("$review-against-ai-patterns", "$visual-artifact-design", "../build-polished-visual-frontends/references/assets-and-imagegen.md") that cannot be navigated from the bundle alone. | 4 / 5 |
Total | 16 / 20 Passed |