Conciseness

The body is dense and assumes Claude's competence — no explanation of what mermaid, DCF, or news aggregation are; steps give formats and rules only. Not 5 because the Output Template section partially duplicates the format specifications already given in Steps 3–6 and could be trimmed.

Actionability

Concrete, executable guidance throughout: exact query template `<主题中文> <主题英文> 最近3天 新闻`, mandated tool `mcp__MiniMax__web_search`, exact per-news line format, exact file name `markdown/<YYYY-MM-DD>_投资者新闻影响日报.md`, and exact svg reference syntax. Not 5 because no filled-in concrete example (e.g. one complete summary line or one assembled query) is shown; the 4-段式 and rules leave small gaps the model must fill.

Workflow Clarity

A clear 6-step sequence with per-step rules (retention counts, dedup, time-window resolution) plus verification guidance — Critical Rule 2 (二次搜索核验金融数字) and the Step 6 no-news edge case act as checkpoints. Not 5 because validation lives in the Critical Rules rather than being embedded as explicit steps in the workflow with fix-and-retry loops (e.g. what to do when a query returns nothing).

Progressive Disclosure

Clear overview with three one-level-deep references, each described with its content and load timing (「Step 1 抓取前必读」「按需加载」「Step 5 出图前加载」), plus an explicit instruction not to load them all at once; all three referenced files exist and match their descriptions. This matches the top anchor well.

Specificity

The description lists multiple concrete actions — 并发抓取近 3 天新闻 (with the 8 default topics enumerated), 按分类总结, 推演对行业和上市公司的影响, 图文并茂输出 markdown 日报 — with concrete output location and scope behavior (若用户提供行业名则只抓该行业). Not score 4 because coverage is comprehensive with no significant gaps in describing what the skill does.

Completeness

Explicitly answers both: what (抓取近 3 天新闻、分类总结、影响推演、图文日报输出到 markdown 目录) and when (「触发场景 - ...时启用」with four concrete trigger phrases). Not 4 because the 'when' clause is explicit and specific rather than merely present.

Trigger Term Quality

Quoted trigger phrases 「抓取最近新闻」「生成投研日报」「分析新闻对 XX 行业或公司的影响」「今天或最近有什么重要新闻」are natural user phrasings. Not 5 because a few common variations are missing (e.g. 市场动态、行业资讯、新闻摘要/简报); not 3 because coverage of natural terms is good and clearly usable.

Distinctiveness Conflict Risk

The investor-impact framing (投研日报、影响推演、上市公司) carves a clear niche with distinct triggers. Not 5 because generic phrases like 「抓取最近新闻」「今天有什么重要新闻」could also match a plain news-search skill, creating minor overlap risk.