Content
71%Weight 40%Scale 1-5Reviews the quality of instructions and guidance provided to agents. Good implementation is clear, handles edge cases, and produces reliable results.
An exceptionally well-written body: terse, concrete, with a fixed output contract, mandatory grounding, and an explicit validation rule. Its one serious defect is that the bundle is incomplete — the taxonomy files it instructs Claude to read on every run and the entire deep-mode procedure file are missing, leaving the skill only partially executable as shipped.
Suggestions
Ship the missing bundle files (rules/deep-mode.md and rules/taxonomy-plan.md, taxonomy-code.md, taxonomy-analysis.md) or inline their content — as bundled, "Read the mode's file on every run" and all of deep mode are unexecutable, and by the skill's own grounding rule the unresolvable paths would be must-fix findings against itself.
State the run order once as a short numbered procedure (parse args → detect mode → announce → persona → grounding → taxonomy walk → steelman → emit report) so the sequence is explicit rather than inferred from section order.
Inline a one-line definition per taxonomy row so baseline plan/code/analysis runs remain actionable even when the rule files are not present.
| Dimension | Reasoning | Score |
|---|---|---|
Conciseness | The body is lean and directive throughout — a mode-detection table, a five-line persona blockquote, a copy-paste output template, and terse hard rules — with zero explanation of concepts Claude already knows and no padding. It matches the 5 anchor (every token earns its place) rather than 4, since no section could be trimmed without losing load-bearing instruction. | 5 / 5 |
Actionability | Baseline guidance is concrete (exact output structure, steelman template, per-mode grounding commands like "grep for at least two referenced files/symbols"), but the core per-mode content is deferred to files absent from the bundle: "Read the mode's file on every run" points to rules/taxonomy-plan|code|analysis.md, none of which exist, and the entire deep-mode procedure lives only in the missing rules/deep-mode.md. That is more than the "minor gaps" of a 4 — key execution details are unresolvable as bundled — but better than a 2 because the inlined taxonomy row names and templates still make a baseline run partially executable. | 3 / 5 |
Workflow Clarity | The sequence is coherent across ordered sections (parse arguments → detect and announce mode → persona → grounding → taxonomy walk → steelman → fixed output → hard rules) with an explicit validation checkpoint ("A referenced file, symbol, or path that does not resolve is itself a must-fix finding") and a hard-rules checklist. It is not 5 because the ordering is implied by section placement rather than stated as one procedure, and the deep-mode branch cannot be verified since its rule file is missing; it is well above 3 because validation and error paths are explicit. | 4 / 5 |
Progressive Disclosure | Structure and signaling are good — a Contents TOC, clearly labeled one-level references, taxonomy detail split out to per-mode files — but scored against the actual bundle, 4 of the 5 referenced paths (rules/deep-mode.md and the three rules/taxonomy-*.md files) do not exist; only references/why-single-pass.md resolves. Broken reference paths are a bigger defect than the "minor organization gaps" of a 4, but the 2 anchor (inlined bulk content, buried references) does not fit. | 3 / 5 |
Total | 15 / 20 Passed |