Evidence-first pull request review with independent critique, selective challenger review, and human handoff.
87
92%
Does it follow best practices?
Impact
87%
1.31xAverage score across 43 eval scenarios
Risky
Do not use without reviewing
{
"context": "Critical: RDS engine change from MySQL to PostgreSQL will cause Terraform to destroy and recreate the database, deleting all production data. Safety guards (deletion_protection, final_snapshot, backups) also removed.",
"type": "weighted_checklist",
"checklist": [
{
"name": "Catches destroy-and-recreate risk",
"description": "Identifies that changing the RDS engine from MySQL to PostgreSQL in Terraform causes a destroy-and-recreate of the database instance (not an in-place migration), which deletes all production data",
"max_score": 15
},
{
"name": "Catches removed safety guards",
"description": "Identifies that deletion_protection is removed, skip_final_snapshot defaults to true, and backup_retention_period is removed — the database can be deleted without a snapshot and has no backups",
"max_score": 10
},
{
"name": "Catches apply_immediately risk",
"description": "Identifies that apply_immediately = true means changes take effect immediately rather than during the maintenance window, compounding the risk of the engine change",
"max_score": 5
},
{
"name": "Risk classified red",
"description": "PR is classified as red due to production database migration with data loss risk",
"max_score": 10
}
]
}evals
scenario-1
scenario-2
scenario-3
scenario-4
scenario-5
scenario-6
scenario-7
scenario-8
scenario-9
scenario-10
scenario-11
scenario-12
scenario-13
scenario-14
scenario-15
scenario-16
scenario-17
scenario-18
scenario-19
scenario-20
scenario-21
scenario-22
scenario-23
scenario-24
scenario-25
scenario-26
scenario-27
scenario-28
scenario-29
scenario-30
scenario-31
scenario-32
scenario-33
scenario-34
scenario-35
scenario-36
scenario-37
scenario-38
scenario-39
scenario-40
scenario-41
scenario-42
scenario-43
rules
skills
challenger-review
finding-synthesizer
fresh-eyes-review
human-review-handoff
pr-evidence-builder
review-retrospective