testland/test-case-review-rubric
Scores an already-written test case against six per-case quality axes (objective specificity, precondition executability, step granularity, step abstraction level, expected-result observability, traceability validity) and six set-level axes (partition coverage, boundary coverage, duplication, orphan and uncovered requirements, tier shape, identifier consistency). Derives a per-case PASS / WEAK / FAIL verdict and a set verdict from it without averaging, and marks every threshold as either standard-backed (ISTQB glossary, ISTQB CTFL v4.0, ISO/IEC/IEEE 29119-3:2021) or practitioner convention (step-count ceiling, tier bands, provenance threshold). Assumes the case field list and field cardinality are already defined by a test-case anatomy reference and judges content quality only. Use when reviewing a batch of hand-written test cases before promoting them to a release suite or handing them to an automation engineer.
80
100%
Does it follow best practices?
Run evals on this skill
Adds up to 20 points to the overall score
View guide
Low
Low-risk findings worth noting
Low
Low-risk findings.
1 low severity finding. Worth noting, but not necessarily harmful.
W011: Third-party content exposure detected (indirect prompt injection risk).
What this means
The skill exposes the agent to untrusted, user-generated content from public third-party sources, creating a risk of indirect prompt injection. This includes browsing arbitrary URLs, reading social media posts or forum comments, and analyzing content from unknown websites.
Why it was flagged
The required runtime workflow ingests only the already-populated fields of a test case (e.g., ID/objective/preconditions/steps/expected results/traceability) provided to the rubric for scoring, which can include outsider-authored free text without first selecting a specific item.
- Audited
- Security analysis